[Early stomach cancer in comparison with advanced stomach cancer. Results of a prospective study of diagnosis and 5-year survival of 131 patients with early stomach cancer and 795 patients with advanced stomach cancer]

Abstract

A multicentre prospective observational study with 22 surgical and 14 pathological units in West-Germany gathered data from 1420 patients with gastric cancer between April 1982 and October 1989, 131 patients with early gastric cancer (EGC) and 795 patients with a resectable advanced gastric cancer (AGC) were selected for comparison. Patients with EGC were younger than those with AGC (49% vs 37% younger than 60 years) and symptoms of an ulcer were found twice in comparison to AGC (40.7% vs 23.7%). EGC in comparison to AGC were frequently multifocal (9.2% vs 3.0%) and located in the middle and lower part of the stomach (83.9% vs 56.8%). Five-year-survival rates of mucosa carcinoma was 84% and of submucosal carcinoma 69% (p = 0.0741). WHO-typing of EGC and AGC were identical. But according to Laurén's classification there were more intestinal types with EGC than with AGC (60.3% vs 51.5%) and less diffuse or mixed types with EGC than with AGC (33.6% vs 44.0%). Five-year-survival rates of diffuse and intestinal types of EGC showed no significant difference (p = 0.19). Extended lymph node dissection was done in only one third of EGC and AGC. Five-year-survival rates of 36 EGC patients with and 95 EGC patients without extended lymph node dissection were 85% versus 72% (p = 0.0916). These results are a hint that systematic lymphadenectomy may have a beneficial effect on survival.