Is learning in problem-based learning cumulative?

Abstract

Problem-based learning (PBL) is generally organized in three phases, involving collaborative and self-directed learning processes. The hypothesis tested here is whether learning in the different phases of PBL is cumulative, with learning in each phase depending on that of the previous phase. The scientific concepts recalled by 218 students at the end of each PBL phase were used to estimate the extent of students' learning. The data were then analyzed using structural equation modeling. Results show that our hypothesized model fits the data well. Alternative hypotheses according to which achievement is predicted either by collaborative learning alone or by self-directed learning alone did not fit the data. We conclude that the learning in each PBL phase is cumulative, and strongly influenced by the earlier phase, thus providing support for the PBL cycle of problem analysis, self-directed learning, and a subsequent reporting phase. We also demonstrate an efficient method to capture and quantify students' learning during the PBL process.

Fig. 1

Hypothesized model on the relationships between the different learning phases of PBL

Fig. 2

Alternative models on the relationships between the different learning phases of PBL

Fig. 3

Distribution of the mean number (+SE) of total, new and repeated relevant concepts recalled at the end of the different learning phases of the PBL process (N = 218)

Fig. 4

Path model of the hypothesized model on relationships between different PBL phases