Additional energetic cost due to belt speed variations when walking on a treadmill

Abstract

Background: Treadmill is commonly used in routine evaluation of walking capacities, especially when dealing with energetic cost, as it allows to measure this motion on a long enough period. However, even when using powerful treadmills, it is impossible to avoid belt speed variations. The objective of this paper was to demonstrate that this instantaneous treadmill speed has to be taken into account in mechanical work calculation during treadmill walking.

Methods: To do so, 11 healthy subjects participated in the study. They walked on treadmill at four different speeds: very slow (0.3 ms(-1)), slow (0.8 ms(-1)), normal (1.4 ms(-1)) and fast (1.9 ms(-1)). To compute P(Vi), the instantaneous mechanical work relatively to the instantaneous treadmill speed, we applied the work-energy theorem in a non-inertial reference frame induced by the treadmill speed variations. This value was then compared to P(V¯), i.e. the instantaneous mechanical work computed with the usual approximation of a constant treadmill speed.

Findings: The speed variations had an average value of 17% for the very slow speed and around 4.5% for the three other and more usual speeds. These variations have a strong influence on instantaneous mechanical work. Indeed, P(V¯) is nearly null when not considering speed variations whereas P(Vi) goes up to 113 mW kg(-1) at higher speeds.

Interpretation: To conclude, our work showed that the instantaneous treadmill speed has to be taken into account in mechanical work computation. This method may provide supplementary information in clinical assessments and analyses of gait. Indeed, when using the same methodology on formerly acquired data in a group of 13 hemiplegic patients, we found that if P(V¯) is not null in this impaired subjects group, P(Vi) is still 30% higher.