Consent for donation after cardiac death: a survey of organ procurement organizations

Abstract

Context: Despite the increasing number of policies governing organ donation after cardiac death (DCD), nothing is presently known about the informed consent process for DCD. Without guidelines, organ procurement organizations (OPOs) are likely to structure the consent process similarly to that for organ donation after brain death (DBD), despite important ethical differences between the 2 modes of organ recovery.

Objective: To describe informed consent practices used by OPOs for DCD.

Design, setting, and participants: Cross-sectional, internet-based survey of the 58 OPOs in the United States.

Main outcome measures: OPO policies and reported levels of physician participation in the consent process for DCD.

Results: Seventeen OPOs completed the survey (29%). Responders and nonresponders did not differ by DCD volume over the last year or last 5 years. None of the OPO's policies require physician involvement in obtaining written informed consent; 94% of policies require only the OPO representative to obtain written consent for DCD and 6% state that either the OPO representative or the treating physician may obtain consent; 71% of OPOs reported that discussions with family regarding DCD occur with the treating physician present less than 51% of the time and 82% indicated that the OPO representative is solely involved in obtaining consent for DCD in the majority of cases. A total of 24% of OPOs require physicians to participate in obtaining consent for procedures performed prior to death exclusively for organ preservation. No differences were found between the OPO consent practices for DCD and DBD.

Conclusions: None of the OPOs responding to this survey have a policy requirement for physician involvement in obtaining consent for DCD. These findings raise questions about the role of physicians in DCD and how best to maintain a patient- and family-centered focus on care for patients at the end of life while supporting organ recovery efforts.