Why are not all chilies hot? A trade-off limits pungency

Abstract

Evolutionary biologists increasingly recognize that evolution can be constrained by trade-offs, yet our understanding of how and when such constraints are manifested and whether they restrict adaptive divergence in populations remains limited. Here, we show that spatial heterogeneity in moisture maintains a polymorphism for pungency (heat) among natural populations of wild chilies (Capsicum chacoense) because traits influencing water-use efficiency are functionally integrated with traits controlling pungency (the production of capsaicinoids). Pungent and non-pungent chilies occur along a cline in moisture that spans their native range in Bolivia, and the proportion of pungent plants in populations increases with greater moisture availability. In high moisture environments, pungency is beneficial because capsaicinoids protect the fruit from pathogenic fungi, and is not costly because pungent and non-pungent chilies grown in well-watered conditions produce equal numbers of seeds. In low moisture environments, pungency is less beneficial as the risk of fungal infection is lower, and carries a significant cost because, under drought stress, seed production in pungent chilies is reduced by 50 per cent relative to non-pungent plants grown in identical conditions. This large difference in seed production under water-stressed (WS) conditions explains the existence of populations dominated by non-pungent plants, and appears to result from a genetic correlation between pungency and stomatal density: non-pungent plants, segregating from intra-population crosses, exhibit significantly lower stomatal density (p = 0.003), thereby reducing gas exchange under WS conditions. These results demonstrate the importance of trait integration in constraining adaptive divergence among populations.

Figure 1.

(a) The natural rainfall gradient across southeastern Bolivia where polymorphic populations occur; pie charts indicate the proportions of pungent plants. (b) The proportion of pungent plants in each population increases as a function of precipitation (r² = 0.83, F_1,19 = 100.5, p ≪ 0.001). Triangles (black, 29%; grey, 45%; white, 88%) indicate the study populations.

Figure 2.

The total seed output for pungent (open) and non-pungent (filled) plants under well-watered and water-stressed conditions. Error bars are ±1 s.e., n = 352, GLM, pungency × treatment p = 0.005.

Figure 3.

Stomatal density (number of stomata per square millimetre) segregates with pungency (n = 19, t-test, p = 0.006) in the F₂ generation of populations generated from crossing pungent by non-pungent parents.