Management of pyogenic liver abscess in the era of computed tomography

Abstract

The advent of high-resolution imaging has allowed earlier diagnosis of pyogenic liver abscess. Because radiologically guided percutaneous drainage (PCD) of liver abscesses is controversial, the authors studied 40 patients with liver abscess admitted to the Toronto Hospital between 1982 and 1987 to determine the role of PCD versus operative drainage (OD). The diagnosis of pyogenic liver abscess was made at autopsy (4 patients), at laparotomy (6) or by radiologically guided aspiration of pus (30). Ultrasonography and computed tomography were highly sensitive (85% and 96% respectively) in detecting liver abscess. Of the 36 patients treated for liver abscess all received antibiotics intravenously; 31 also underwent a drainage procedure. Treatment with antibiotics alone was associated with a success rate of 80% and a death rate of 20%. The success rate for those who had PCD was 75% with a death rate of 13%; 2 patients in this group of 16 subsequently required OD for cure. In the 15 patients initially treated with OD, success and death rates were 87% and 13% respectively. For solitary abscesses, success rates wer comparable for PCD and OD (86% and 90% respectively). For unilobar multiple abscesses the success rate was 100% for both PCD and OD, but for bilobar multiple abscesses the rates were only 40% and 67% respectively. Complication rates were similar for both methods of drainage. The authors conclude that pyogenic liver abscess can now be safely and efficaciously managed with a combination of antibiotics and PCD.