Applicability of two methods of mixed dentition analysis in a contemporary Indian population sample

Abstract

Aim: More than 10 years experience in implementing the Tanaka Johnston and Moyers methods has shown that they overestimate the sizes of unerupted canines and premolars when used in populations other than the Caucasian. This study was designed to assess the applicability of the two most commonly used methods of mixed dentition analysis and to attempt to derive a more accurate and precise formula to predict the sizes of the unerupted premolars and canines in a sample of Indian population.

Materials and methods: The sample included 200 study models (100 male, 100 female). Tanaka Johnston's and Moyer's equations were applied to this sample and the mean differences between the actual and estimated tooth widths were determined. New regression equations were derived using lower first molars and incisors as the predictors.

Results: The mean difference between the actual and estimated values of canines and premolars using Tanaka Johnston's and Moyers methods were clinically and statistically significant. Therefore new regression equations were derived taking lower first molars and incisors as the predictors for both sexes. On validation, these equations were found to be accurate and precise for this population.

Conclusion: It is recommended to use these equations as a method of mixed dentition analysis for the Indian population.