Surgical correction of ventricular septal defects in black and white children--an 11-year study

Abstract

The clinical and ECG features, anatomical subtypes and outcome in 309 children (169 black; 140 white; 58% female) who underwent surgical closure of ventricular septal defects (VSDs) are presented. Clinical presentation was more severe in the black children; with recurrent pulmonary infections in 65% blacks compared with 34% whites. Congestive cardiac failure was noted in 60% blacks and in 37% whites. At cardiac catheterisation a left to right shunt greater than 2.5/1 was found in 45.5% of the black and in 39.3% of the white children. Severe pulmonary hypertension (greater than 80% of systemic systolic pressure) was evenly distributed in both groups. Of the 140 white children, 74.3% underwent surgery under the age of 2 years compared with 68.6% of the 169 blacks. A perimembranous VSD was found in 65% of patients in each group. Infundibular (muscular outlet) defects were observed in 28.6% of white and 30.8% of black children. Left axis deviation (LAD) on ECG was found in 11.9% of white and 9.2% of black patients; and 93% of the total of 27 cases had a perimembranous defect. Early mortality was 3.6% in white and 7.1% among the black children. Of the 17 fatal cases in the total group, 16 had severe pulmonary hypertension. It is concluded that: (i) operative results compared favourably with those reported elsewhere; (ii) the anatomical subtypes occurred with equal frequency in both ethnic groups; and (iii) this was also the case for LAD on ECG, which was most commonly associated with a perimembranous VSD.