[Phimosis: dorsal slit or circumcision?]

Abstract

Introduction: Phimosis is perhaps one of the most frequent consultation on pediatric surgery clinics throught the world. The aim of this study is to compare the two procedures more frequently performed in our hospital: dorsal slit and circumcision. PATIENTS Y METHODS: Retrospective study of 1698 patients who were admitted for elective surgical treatment of phimosis between 2003 and 2009. We analyzed age, surgical and anesthethic times, surgical technique and complications. We also did transversal descriptive study through telephonic survey on parents and patients older than 16 years old.

Results: There was 76.6% of dorsal slit (n = 1300) and 23.4% (n= 398) of circumcisions. Mean age was 7.15 years y mean time of follow up was 42.3 months. Surgical time was significantly higher in circumcision (p < 0.0001). There were 3% (n = 51) of reoperations, no differences between groups. We didn't find differences in postoperative stenosis, but bleeding was more frequent in circumcision group (1.7%; p = 0.03). There were no differences on parental appreciation of postoperative pain, or functional and esthetic satisfaction between groups.

Conclusions: We didn't find differences on subjective satisfaction between groups. Even if there are differences n postoperative bleeding, global incidence is very low. In our experience both techniques are valid and safe, so surgeon and parents must jointly make the decision.