Analysis of complete response by MRI following neoadjuvant chemotherapy predicts pathological tumor responses differently for molecular subtypes of breast cancer

Abstract

In the present study, clinical tumor response following neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NAC) was diagnosed by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and clinicopathological factors, including molecular subtypes at baseline, were analyzed for correlations with pathological tumor responses. In addition, clinicopathological factors were analyzed for a correlation with the MRI capacity to predict pathological complete response (pCR). Clinical tumor response evaluated by MRI following NAC was determined as a clinical CR (cCR) or a residual tumor. cCR was confirmed if no gadolinium enhancement or an enhancement equal to or less than that of glandular tissue was observed in any phase of the MRI. Pathological tumor responses following NAC were classified into grades 0 (no change) to 3 (no residual invasive cancer) according to criteria of the Japanese Breast Cancer Society. pCR was defined as grade 3 in the present study. Of 264 cases of invasive breast cancer in 260 patients (4 synchronous bilateral breast cancer cases), 59 (22%) were diagnosed by MRI following NAC as cCR and 98 (37%) were pathologically diagnosed as pCR. In terms of predicting pCR by MRI, the sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) were 44, 90, 73, 73 and 73%, respectively. Tumor size, hormone receptor status, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) status, molecular subtype and histological type were significantly correlated with pathological tumor responses. pCR rates increased in the following order: luminal/HER2-negative (14%), luminal/HER2-positive (32%), triple-negative (46%) and non-luminal/HER2-positive (73%) tumors. Sensitivity and specificity were the highest (60 and 100%, respectively) in triple-negative tumors. PPV decreased in the following order: triple-negative (100%), non-luminal/HER2-positive (92%), luminal/HER2-positive (46%) and luminal/HER2-negative (33%) tumors. In conclusion, MRI evaluation is useful for predicting pCR following NAC, particularly for triple-negative tumors.

Figure 1

A false-positive case of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) predicting a pathological complete response. (A) No gadolinium enhancement was detected by MRI. (B and C) Histological analysis indicates scattered distribution of invasive breast cancer cells was identified in a scarred area (magnification, ×2 and ×20, respectively). In this case, pathological tumor response was determined as grade 2 according to the Japanese Breast Cancer Society criteria.

Figure 2

A false-negative case of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) predicting a pathological complete response. (A) Gadolinium enhancement was detected by MRI. (B and C) No cancer cells were identified in the scarred area (magnification, ×2 and ×20, respectively).