Working alliance and its relationship to outcomes in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of antipsychotic medication

Abstract

Background: Long acting injections (LAI) have been associated with perceptions of coercion in cross sectional studies but there have been no longitudinal studies of the effects on clinical relationships with newer depot medications.

Method: Randomized controlled trial with (50) participants with a diagnosis of schizophrenia randomized to risperidone LAI or oral atypical antipsychotic medication. The main outcome was the Working Alliance Inventory (WAI) with background variables (symptoms, side effect, social functioning, quality of life) measured before randomization and at two years.

Results: At follow-up (14 risperidone LAI and 16 oral medication) analyses including predictors of missing data and baseline score showed a trend for those on risperidone LAI to reduce WAI score and those on oral medication showing no change. Sensitivity analyses showed (i) a significant detrimental effect of LAI on WAI and (ii) the pattern of results was not affected by change in symptoms over the study.

Conclusion: This is the first study to show that the prescription of depot atypical depot medication is associated with detrimental effects on clinical relationships after 2 years of continual treatment.

Figure 1

Predicted mean WAI scores at time 2 from the regression model after adjusting for trial arm, exacerbations at 12 weeks and baseline WAI scores.