Evaluation in chimpanzees of vaccinia virus recombinants that express the surface glycoproteins of human respiratory syncytial virus

Abstract

The immunogenicity and protective efficacy of recombinant vaccinia viruses that express the two major protective antigens of human respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), the F and G glycoproteins, were evaluated in chimpanzees. In previous studies in rodents and monkeys the F and G proteins expressed by the same recombinants were highly immunogenic and induced high levels of resistance to RSV replication following subsequent challenge. In contrast, in chimpanzees, a single intradermal immunization induced only moderate levels of F and G-specific serum antibodies as measured by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and these antibodies did not efficiently neutralize RSV infectivity in vitro. This poor antibody response in chimpanzees to the F and G glycoproteins occurred despite efficient replication of the vaccinia virus vector as evidenced by lesion size and serum antibody response to vaccinia virus. Upon intranasal RSV challenge, it was observed that prior immunization with the F and G recombinants effected only a marginal reduction in the magnitude and duration of RSV shedding from the nose and trachea and did not reduce illness. However, the RSV challenge induced a strong secondary antibody response, resulting in very high titres (greater than 8000 reciprocal mean titre) of serum neutralizing antibodies. The poor protective efficacy observed here is discussed with regard to the permissiveness of the chimpanzee to RSV replication, the general requirements for effective immunization against RSV, and the limitations of experimental animals for evaluating candidate RSV vaccines.