Gender Differences in the Relationship Between Physical Activity and Smoking Among Psychiatrically Hospitalized Adolescents

Abstract

Physical activity has been identified as a protective factor with regard to tobacco use, such that physically active adolescents are less likely to initiate smoking, and smokers are less physically active than non-smokers. These findings, along with the well-documented benefits of exercise on mood and well-being in adults, have stimulated interest in exercise-based smoking cessation interventions. However, little research has explored the relationship between physical activity and smoking characteristics within adolescent smokers. Also, gender differences in adolescents' motives for smoking and exercise may have implications for intervention development, especially in clinical populations. The current study explored the relationship between physical activity and smoking in a sample of adolescent smokers (N = 191) and non-smokers (N = 48) receiving inpatient psychiatric treatment (61% female, mean age 15.3 years). Results indicated that smokers were less likely to be physically active than non-smokers. Additionally, there was a consistent pattern of gender differences in the relationship between smoking and physical activity within smokers. Specifically, physically active male smokers were less nicotine dependent and less prone to withdrawal, and had a trend toward greater motivation to quit, than their non-active counterparts. In contrast, physically active female smokers did not differ in dependence or withdrawal and were less motivated to quit than non-active female smokers. Taken together, these results suggest that within clinical populations of adolescent females, smoking and exercise may be used jointly as weight control strategies. Exercise-based interventions for smoking cessation for adolescent females, especially clinical populations, should address weight and body image concerns.

Keywords: exercise; inpatient; psychiatric; tobacco; youth.

Figure 1

Significant interaction of gender and physical activity status on nicotine dependence (FTQ score), p = .007. Simple effects analyses revealed that physically active males were less nicotine dependent than non-active males, p = .006.

Figure 2

Significant interaction of gender and physical activity status on smoking behavior intention after hospital discharge (ranged from 1-5; 1 = smoke more than I used to, 5 = quit smoking completely), p = .005. Simple effects analyses revealed that physically active females had significantly weaker intention to reduce or quit smoking than non-active females, p = .03; for males the relationship was in the opposite direction, p = .05.