Surgical targets for dystonic tremor: considerations between the globus pallidus and ventral intermediate thalamic nucleus

Abstract

Dystonic tremor (DT) is characterized by coexisting tremor and abnormal dystonic posturing in the same segment. DT is often medically refractory and DBS is an important therapeutic option. However, the optimal surgical target for DT remains uncertain with Vim, GPi and zona incerta previously reported as effective. We retrospectively reviewed the outcome data from all patients with DT involving at least one upper extremity who underwent DBS at Vanderbilt University from July 2006 to July 2010. We evaluated the improvement of tremor and dystonia after their response to DBS was judged to be maximal. Ten patients met the inclusion criteria. Vim was targeted in four patients and three had unilateral procedure and one bilateral Vim DBS. GPi was targeted in four patients with bilateral DBS procedure in every patient from this subgroup. A combined bilateral GPi and unilateral Vim DBS was performed in two patients. The best results for tremor control were observed in patients with Vim DBS but they had persisting mild dystonia. Patients with GPi DBS had average DT improvement by approximately 50% but their dystonia symptoms were markedly improved. We propose that the patients with DT with a mild dystonia should be considered for Vim DBS procedure and the coexistence of severe DT and dystonia may be successfully controlled by combined GPi and Vim DBS surgeries.