Interventions for hiring, retaining and training district health systems managers in low- and middle-income countries
- PMID: 23633365
- PMCID: PMC7386782
- DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD009035.pub2
Interventions for hiring, retaining and training district health systems managers in low- and middle-income countries
Abstract
Background: District managers are playing an increasingly important role in determining the performance of health systems in low- and middle-income countries as a result of decentralization.
Objectives: To assess the effectiveness of interventions to hire, retain and train district health systems managers in low- and middle-income countries.
Search methods: We searched a wide range of international databases, including the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE and EMBASE. We also searched online resources of international agencies, including the World Bank, to find relevant grey literature. Searches were conducted in December 2011.
Selection criteria: District health systems managers are those persons who are responsible for overseeing the operations of the health system within a defined, subnational geographical area that is designated as a district. Hiring and retention interventions include those that aim to increase the attractiveness of district management positions, as well as those related to hiring and retention processes, such as private contracting. Training interventions include education programs to develop future managers and on-the-job training programs for current managers. To be included, studies needed to use one of the following study designs: randomized controlled trial, nonrandomized controlled trial, controlled before-and-after study, and interrupted time series analysis.
Data collection and analysis: We report measures of effect in the same way that the primary study authors have reported them. Due to the varied nature of interventions included in this review we could not pool data across studies.
Main results: Two studies met our inclusion criteria. The findings of one study conducted in Cambodia provide low quality evidence that private contracts with international nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) for district health systems management ('contracting-in') may improve health care access and utilization. Contracting-in increased use of antenatal care by 28% and use of public facilities by 14%. However, contracting-in was not found to have an effect on population health outcomes. The findings of the other study provide low quality evidence that intermittent training courses over 18 months may improve district health system managers' performance. In three countries in Latin America, managers who did not receive the intermittent training courses had between 2.4 and 8.3 times more management deficiencies than managers who received the training courses. No studies that aimed to investigate interventions for retaining district health systems managers met our study selection criteria for inclusion in this review.
Authors' conclusions: There is low quality evidence that contracting-in may improve health care accessibility and utilization and that intermittent training courses may improve district health systems managers' performance. More evidence is required before firm conclusions can be drawn regarding the effectiveness of these interventions in diverse settings. Other interventions that might be promising candidates for hiring and retaining (e.g., government regulations, professional support programs) as well as training district health systems managers (e.g., in-service workshops with on-site support) have not been adequately investigated.
Conflict of interest statement
None known.
Update of
References
References to studies included in this review
Bloom 2006 {published data only}
-
- Bloom E, Bhushan I, Clingingsmith D, Hong R, King E, Kremer M, et al. Contracting for health: evidence from Cambodia. Brooking Institution 2006.
Diaz‐Monsalve 2004 {published data only}
-
- Diaz‐Monsalve SJ. The impact of health‐management training programs in Latin America on job performance. Cad Saude Publica 2004;20(4):1110‐20. [PUBMED: 15300305] - PubMed
References to studies excluded from this review
Agyepong 1999 {published data only}
-
- Agyepong IA. Reforming health service delivery at the district level in Ghana: the perspective of a district medical officer. Health Policy and Planning 1999;14(1):59‐69. [PUBMED: 10351470] - PubMed
Ambegaokar 2004 {published data only}
-
- Ambegaokar M, Lush L. Family planning and sexual health organizations: management lessons for health system reform. Health Policy and Planning 2004;19(S1):i22‐i30. [PUBMED: 15452012] - PubMed
Ayaya 2007 {published data only}
-
- Ayaya SO, Liechty E, Conway JH, Kamau T, Esamai FO. Training needs for mid‐level managers and immunization coverage in Western Kenya. East African Medical Journal 2007;84(7):342‐52. [PUBMED: 17886429] - PubMed
Bärnighausen 2009 {published data only}
Basri 2009 {published data only}
Briggs 2010 {published data only}
-
- Briggs DS, Tejativaddhana P, Cruickshank M, Fraser J, Campbell S. The Thai‐Australian Health Alliance: developing health management capacity and sustainability for primary health care services. Education for Health 2010;23(3):457. [PUBMED: 21290364] - PubMed
Byskov 2009 {published data only}
-
- Byskov J, Bloch P, Blystad A, Hurtig AK, Fylkesnes K, Kamuzora P, et al. Accountable priority setting for trust in health systems—the need for research into a new approach for strengthening sustainable health action in developing countries. Health Research Policy and Systems 2009;7:23. [PUBMED: 19852834] - PMC - PubMed
Clark 2001 {published data only}
-
- Clark J, Underwood R. Management development of clinicians in Indonesia. Medical Teacher 2001;23(1):97‐99. [PUBMED: 11260753] - PubMed
Comolet 1997 {published data only}
-
- Comolet TM, Rakotomalala RA, Rasolomahefa D. [Evaluation of a supervision program of health centers at the district level in Madagascar]. Sante 1997;7(2):103‐8. [PUBMED: 9273116] - PubMed
Conn 1996 {published data only}
-
- Conn CP, Jenkins P, Touray SO. Strengthening health management: experience of district teams in The Gambia. Health Policy and Planning 1996;11(1):64‐71. [PUBMED: 10155879] - PubMed
De Brouwere 1996 {published data only}
-
- Brouwere V, Balen H. Hands‐on training in health district management. World Health Forum 1996;17(3):271‐3. [PUBMED: 8756133] - PubMed
Dieleman 2009 {published data only}
Djibuti 2009 {published data only}
Egger 2007 {published data only}
-
- Egger D, Ollier E. Managing the health Millennium Development Goals: the challenge of management strengthening: lessons from three countries. WHO: Geneva 2007.
Enkhtuya 2009 {published data only}
-
- Enkhtuya B, Badamusuren T, Dondog N, Khandsuren L, Elbegtuya N, Jargal G, et al. Reaching every district ‐ development and testing of a health micro‐planning strategy for reaching difficult to reach populations in Mongolia. Rural Remote Health 2009;9(2):1045. [PUBMED: 19368489] - PubMed
Espino 2004 {published data only}
-
- Espino F, Beltran M, Carisma B. Malaria control through municipalities in the Philippines: struggling with the mandate of decentralized health programme management. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 2004;19(Suppl 1):S155‐66. [PUBMED: 15686067] - PubMed
Fonn 2011 {published data only}
-
- Fonn S, Ray S, Blaauw D. Innovation to improve health care provision and health systems in sub‐Saharan Africa ‐ promoting agency in mid‐level workers and district managers. Global Public Health 2011;6(6):657‐68. [PUBMED: 20582782] - PubMed
Grobler 2009 {published data only}
-
- Grobler L, Marais BJ, Mabunda SA, Marindi PN, Reuter H, Volmink J. Interventions for increasing the proportion of health professionals practising in rural and other underserved areas. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2009, Issue 1. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD005314.pub2; PUBMED: 19160251] - DOI - PubMed
Israr 2006 {published data only}
-
- Israr SM, Islam A. Good governance and sustainability: a case study from Pakistan. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 2006;21(4):313‐25. [PUBMED: 17175733] - PubMed
Jack 2003 {published data only}
-
- Jack W. Contracting for health services: an evaluation of recent reforms in Nicaragua. Health Policy and Planning 2003;18(2):195‐204. [PUBMED: 12740324] - PubMed
Jain 1999 {published data only}
-
- Jain SC, Barkat A, Lundeen K, Faisel AJ, Ahmed T, Islam MS. Improving family planning program performance through management training: the 3Cs paradigm. Journal of Health and Population in Developing Countries 1999;2(1):1‐25. [PUBMED: 12349106] - PubMed
Jones 2008 {published data only}
-
- Jones C, Abeku TA, Rapuoda B, Okia M, Cox J. District‐based malaria epidemic early warning systems in East Africa: perceptions of acceptability and usefulness among key staff at health facility, district and central levels. Social Science and Medicine 2008;67(2):292‐300. [PUBMED: 18450352] - PubMed
Kahindo 2011 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
-
- Kahindo M, Schirvel C, Karemere H, Mitangala P, Wodon A, Porignon D. Reorganization of provincial level of health system in North Kivu and oriental Kasai, Democratic Republic of Congo [Gouvernance et soutien provincial au district de sante en RD‐Congo]. Medecine Tropicale 2011;71:147‐51. - PubMed
Kalita 2009 {published data only}
Koehlmoos 2009 {published data only}
Krishnamurthy 2007 {published data only}
-
- Krishnamurthy M, Zaidi S, Kalita A. Supporting community health and district planning strategies in Bihar. Centre for Development Finance Working Paper Series. Institute for Financial Management and Research 2007:http://www.icicifoundation.org/media/publication/Supporting_Community_He.....
Lagarde 2009 {published data only}
Liu 2007 {published data only}
-
- Liu X, Hotchkiss DR, Bose S. The impact of contracting‐out on health system performance: a conceptual framework. Health Policy 2007;82(2):200‐11. [PUBMED: 17055607] - PubMed
Liu 2008 {published data only}
-
- Liu X, Hotchkiss DR, Bose S. The effectiveness of contracting‐out primary health care services in developing countries: a review of the evidence. Health Policy and Planning 2008;23(1):1‐13. [PUBMED: 17999986] - PubMed
Loevinsohn 2005 {published data only}
-
- Loevinsohn B, Harding A. Buying results? Contracting for health service delivery in developing countries. Lancet 2005;366(9486):676‐81. [PUBMED: 16112305] - PubMed
Loevinsohn 2009 {published data only}
-
- Loevinsohn B, Haq IU, Couffinhal A, Pande A. Contracting‐in management to strengthen publicly financed primary health services‐‐the experience of Punjab, Pakistan. Health Policy 2009;91(1):17‐23. [PUBMED: 19070931] - PubMed
MacFarlane 2006 {published data only}
-
- Macfarlane C, Joffe AL, Naidoo S. Training of disaster managers at a masters degree level: from emergency care to managerial control. Emergency Medicine Australasia 2006;18(5‐6):451‐6. [PUBMED: 17083633] - PubMed
Mansour 2010 {published data only}
McEwan 2001 {published data only}
McPake 1994 {published data only}
-
- McPake B, Banda EE. Contracting out of health services in developing countries. Health Policy and Planning 1994;9(1):25‐30. [PUBMED: 10133098] - PubMed
McPake 1995 {published data only}
-
- McPake B, Hongoro C. Contracting out of clinical services in Zimbabwe. Social Science and Medicine 1995;41(1):13‐24. [PUBMED: 7667666] - PubMed
Mills 1998 {published data only}
-
- Mills A. To contract or not to contract? Issues for low and middle income countries. Health Policy and Planning 1998;13(1):32‐40. [PUBMED: 10178183] - PubMed
Mills 2004 {published data only}
-
- Mills A, Palmer N, Gilson L, McIntyre D, Schneider H, Sinanovic E, et al. The performance of different models of primary care provision in Southern Africa. Social Science and Medicine 2004;59(5):931‐43. [PUBMED: 15186895] - PubMed
Mugisha 2009 {published data only}
-
- Mugisha JF. Using information and communication technology to revitalise continuing professional development for rural health professionals: evidence from a pilot project. Rural Remote Health 2009;9(4):1222. [PUBMED: 19891518] - PubMed
Mutabaruka 2010 {published data only}
-
- Mutabaruka E, Dochez C, Nshimirimana D, Meheus A. Evaluation of mid‐level management training in immunisation in the African region. East African Journal of Public Health 2010;7(1):37‐43. [PUBMED: 21413570] - PubMed
Naimoli 2003 {published data only}
-
- Naimoli JF, Vaillancourt D. Partnerships within the public sector to achieve health objectives: performance‐based management in an evolving decentralized public health system in West Africa – The case of Burkina Faso. World Bank 2003:http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTHSD/Resources/topics/Services/fina....
Nankumbi 2011 {published data only}
Newbrander 2011 {published data only}
-
- Newbrander W, Peercy C, Shepherd‐Banigan M, Vergeer P. A tool for assessing management capacity at the decentralized level in a fragile state. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 2012;27(4):276‐94. [PUBMED: 22034286] - PubMed
Nigenda 2009 {published data only}
Okamoto 2009 {published data only}
-
- Okamoto M, Nhea S, Akashi H, Kawaguchi L, Ui S, Kinoshita M, et al. Developing institutional capacity of health service system management at the district level in rural Cambodia. Bioscience Trends 2009;3(6):239‐46. [PUBMED: 20103853] - PubMed
Omar 2009 {published data only}
Omaswa 1997 {published data only}
Palmer 2006 {published data only}
Pappaioanou 2003 {published data only}
-
- Pappaioanou M, Malison M, Wilkins K, Otto B, Goodman RA, Churchill RE, et al. Strengthening capacity in developing countries for evidence‐based public health: the data for decision‐making project. Social Science and Medicine 2003;57(10):1925‐37. [PUBMED: 14499516] - PubMed
Perry 2008 {published data only}
Sandiford 1994 {published data only}
-
- Sandiford P, Kanga GJ, Ahmed AM. The management of health services in Tanzania: a plea for health sector reform. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 1994;9(4):295‐308. [PUBMED: 10172194] - PubMed
Siddiqi 2006 {published data only}
Sinha 2007 {published data only}
-
- Sinha T, Ranson MK, Chatterjee M, Mills A. Management initiatives in a community‐based health insurance scheme. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 2007;22(4):289‐300. [PUBMED: 17708589] - PubMed
Soeters 2003 {published data only}
-
- Soeters R, Griffiths F. Improving government health services through contract management: a case from Cambodia. Health Policy and Planning 2003;18(1):74‐83. [PUBMED: 12582110] - PubMed
Talbot 2009 {published data only}
Tanaka 1999 {published data only}
-
- Tanaka OY, Nemes MI, Novaes HM, Bastos MG, Cesar CL, Riedel LF. [Training of local health managers: process of identification of strategic actions]. Revista Saude Publica 1999;33(3):219‐29. [PUBMED: 10456994] - PubMed
Tarimo 1989 {published data only}
-
- Tarimo E, Fowkes FG. Strengthening the backbone of primary health care. World Health Forum 1989;10(1):74‐9. [PUBMED: 2751813] - PubMed
Topçuoğlu 2004 {published data only}
-
- Topçuoğlu E, Nawar, L. Follow‐up evaluation of the leadership development program for the Ministry of Health and Population, Egypt. Management Sciences for Health 2004:http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACA370.pdf.
Trap 2001 {published data only}
-
- Trap B, Todd CH, Moore H, Laing R. The impact of supervision on stock management and adherence to treatment guidelines: a randomized controlled trial. Health Policy and Planning 2001;16(3):273‐80. [PUBMED: 11527868] - PubMed
USAID 2009 {published data only}
-
- USAID Global Health Technical Assistance Project. Evaluation of the leadership, management, and sustainability (LMS) project. United States Agency for International Development 2009.
Van den Broucke 2010 {published data only}
-
- Broucke S, Jooste H, Tlali M, Moodley V, Zyl G, Nyamwaya D, et al. Strengthening the capacity for health promotion in South Africa through international collaboration. Global Health Promotion 2010;17(Suppl 2):6‐16. [PUBMED: 20595334] - PubMed
Varpilah 2011 {published data only}
Vian 2007 {published data only}
WGIHSPT 1995 {published data only}
-
- Working Group on Innovations of Health Systems and Professional Training. [Curriculum design for the Master of Public Health using an in‐service education model]. Salud Publica de Mexico 1995;37:63‐74. [PUBMED: 7754431] - PubMed
Yaping 2002 {published data only}
-
- Yaping D, Stanton P. Evaluation of the health services management training course of Jiangsu, China. Australian Health Review 2002;25(3):161‐70. [PUBMED: 12136558] - PubMed
Additional references
Anand 2011
-
- Anand S, Bärnighausen T. Health workers at the core of the health system: framework and research issues. Health Policy 2011;105(2‐3):185‐91. [PUBMED: 22154420] - PubMed
Bossert 1998
-
- Bossert T. Analyzing the decentralization of health systems in developing countries: decision space, innovation and performance. Social Science and Medicine 1998;47(10):1513‐27. [PUBMED: 9823047] - PubMed
Bossert 2002
-
- Bossert T, Beauvais JC. Decentralization of health systems in Ghana, Zambia, Uganda and the Philippines: a comparative analysis of decision space. Health Policy and Planning 2002;17(1):14‐31. [PUBMED: 11861583] - PubMed
EPOC 2008
-
- EPOC. Resources for review authors: risk of bias criteria. [Accessed: 30 June 2010]. Available at: http://epoc.cochrane.org/epoc‐resources‐review‐authors.
Grundy 2003
-
- Grundy J, Healy V, Gorgolon L, Sandig E. Overview of devolution of health services in the Philippines. Rural Remote Health 2003;3(2):220. [PUBMED: 15877513] - PubMed
Hanson 2003
-
- Hanson KM, Ranson K, Oliveira‐Cruz V, Mills A. Expanding access to priority health interventions: a framework for understanding the constraints to scaling‐up. Journal of International Development 2003;15:1‐14.
Harrison 2004
-
- Harrison GW, List JA. Field experiments. Journal of Economic Literature 2004;42(4):1009‐55.
Jones 2009
Kruk 2008
-
- Kruk ME, Freedman LP. Assessing health system performance in developing countries: a review of the literature. Health Policy 2008;85(3):263‐76. [PUBMED: 17931736] - PubMed
Mangham 2010
-
- Mangham LJ, Hanson K. Scaling up in international health: what are the key issues?. Health Policy and Planning 2010;25(2):85‐96. [PUBMED: 20071454] - PubMed
Oliveira‐Cruz 2003
-
- Oliveira‐Cruz V, Hanson K, Mills A. Approaches to overcoming constraints to effective health service delivery: a review of the evidence. Journal of International Development 2003;15:41‐65.
Segall 2003
-
- Segall M. District health systems in a neoliberal world: a review of five key policy areas. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 2003;18 Suppl 1:5‐26. [PUBMED: 14661938] - PubMed
Travis 2004
-
- Travis P, Bennett S, Haines A, Pang T, Bhutta Z, Hyder AA, et al. Overcoming health‐systems constraints to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. Lancet 2004;364(9437):900‐6. [PUBMED: 15351199] - PubMed
Willis‐Shattuck 2008
World Bank 2010
-
- World Bank. Country Classification. [Accessed 1 July 2010]. Available at: http://go.worldbank.org/K2CKM78CC0.
World Health Organization 2007
-
- World Health Organization. Building leadership and management capacity in health. [Accessed 24 May 2010] Available at: www.who.int/management/FrameworkBrochure.pdf 2007.
World Health Organization 2010
-
- World Health Organization. Increasing access to health workers in remote and rural areas through improved retention. Geneva: WHO 2010. - PubMed
Publication types
MeSH terms
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
Other Literature Sources
Miscellaneous
