Noncompliance with Universal Precautions Policy: why do physicians and nurses recap needles?

Abstract

In 1987 the Centers for Disease Control published a Universal Precautions Policy establishing blood and body fluid procedures to be used consistently with all patients. An important and unequivocal Universal Precautions Policy recommendation with regard to avoidance of needlestick injuries is that needles should never be recapped. We examined the recapping-related attitudes and behaviors of physicians and nurses at four large teaching hospitals with patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome and with Universal Precautions Policy in-service training programs. Compliance was found to be considerably less than optimal. According to unannounced needle counts in disposal boxes, the percentage of recapped needles was always greater than 25% and exceeded 50% in four instances. Recapping was related to inadequate knowledge, concerns about personal risk, forgetfulness, being "too busy" to follow the Universal Precautions Policy, and the misperception that recapping is a way to avoid needlestick injury. Strategies are suggested to improve and supplement traditional in-service education.