Kinematic evaluation of movement smoothness in golf: relationship between the normalized jerk cost of body joints and the clubhead

Abstract

Background: When the human body is introduced to a new motion or movement, it learns the placement of different body parts, sequential muscle control, and coordination between muscles to achieve necessary positions, and it hones this new skill over time and repetition. Previous studies have demonstrated definite differences in the smoothness of body movements with different levels of training, i.e., amateurs compared with professionals. Therefore, we tested the hypothesis that skilled golfers swing a driver with a smoother motion than do unskilled golfers. In addition, the relationship between the smoothness of body joints and that of the clubhead was evaluated to provide further insight into the mechanism of smooth golf swing.

Methods: Two subject groups (skilled and unskilled) participated in the experiment. The skilled group comprised 20 male professional golfers registered with the Korea Professional Golf Association, and the unskilled group comprised 19 amateur golfers who enjoy golf as a hobby. Six infrared cameras (VICON460 system) were used to record the 3D trajectories of markers attached to the clubhead and body segments, and the resulting data was evaluated with kinematic analysis. A physical quantity called jerk was calculated to investigate differences in smoothness during downswing between the two study groups.

Results: The hypothesis that skilled golfers swing a driver with a smoother motion than do unskilled golfers was supported. The normalized jerk of the clubhead of skilled golfers was lower than that of unskilled golfers in the anterior/posterior, medial/lateral, and proximal/distal directions. Most human joints, especially in the lower body, had statistically significant lower normalized jerk values in the skilled group. In addition, the normalized jerk of the skilled group's lower body joints had a distinct positive correlation with the normalized jerk of the clubhead with r = 0.657 (p < 0.01).

Conclusions: The result of this study showed that skilled golfers have smoother swings than unskilled golfers during the downswing and revealed that the smoothness of a clubhead trajectory is related more to the smoothness of the lower body joints than that of the upper body joints. These findings can be used to understand the mechanisms behind smooth golf swings and, eventually, to improve golf performance.

Figure 1

Golf swing analysis system.

Figure 2

Anatomical reference system of the pelvis and femur.

Figure 3

3D traces of a clubhead during the downswing in the skilled (a) and unskilled golfers (b).

Figure 4

Clubhead trajectory and jerk of representative skilled (a) and unskilled (b) golfers during the downswing. The upper, middle and lower panels represent the values of x-, y- and z-axis of the local reference system respectively.

Figure 5

Comparisons of the NJ of the clubhead between skilled and unskilled golfers during the downswing.

Figure 6

Correlation between the NJ of the lower (Top) and upper body (Bottom) and the clubhead in the downswing of the skilled (a) and unskilled golfers (b).