Coming out in color: racial/ethnic differences in the relationship between level of sexual identity disclosure and depression among lesbians

Abstract

Disclosing one's sexual minority identity, or "coming out," has varying effects on the mental health of lesbians. Previous research indicates a negative association between disclosure and depression. However, these findings are based on research with White lesbians. To date, there is a paucity of studies that examined how the relationship between disclosure and depression may differ by race/ethnicity among lesbians. To address this gap, we examined the relationship between disclosure and depression among African American (26.5%), Latina (19.7%), and White (53.8%) self-identified lesbians (N = 351) in 2 survey-interviews (∼ 3-years apart). Over 50% of the participants reported a history of lifetime depression at baseline and 35.9% reported depression at Time 2 (T2). Disclosure levels varied: 78.9% had disclosed to their mother, 58.4% to their father, and 83.3% to a sibling. The mean level for disclosure to nonfamily individuals was 6.29 (SD 2.64; range 0-9). Disclosure results varied by race/ethnicity showing African American lesbians (vs. White lesbians) were less likely to disclose to nonfamily individuals when controlling for covariates. Results for the relationship between disclosure and depression showed disclosure to either parent or sibling was not associated with depression for the total sample. Among Latinas only, disclosure to nonfamily individuals was associated with less depression. Additional research is needed to explore racial/ethnic differences in disclosure with certain individuals and to better understand the relation between disclosure and depression. Findings have implications for reducing overall rates of depression among lesbians living with multiple-minority identities.

Figure 1. Interaction Effects of Nonfamily Disclosure by Race/Ethnicity on Depression

This figure adjusted for the six covariates, four disclosure variables, and two dummy variables representing race (African American and Latina), using White lesbians as the reference group. The x-axis represents the level of disclosure to nonfamily members based on a scale range of 0 to 9. The y-axis represents the predicted probability of depression ranging from 0 to 1. The slopes show the interaction effects of nonfamily disclosure by race/ethnicity on depression at Time 2.