Restless legs syndrome in non-dialysis renal patients: is it really that common?

Abstract

Background: Sleep disorders are frequent in chronic kidney disease (CKD). Among them, restless legs syndrome (RLS) may affect up to 60% of patients on dialysis, and it has been related to a poor quality of life and higher cardiovascular risk. Despite its high prevalence in advanced stages of renal disease, RLS frequency in non-dialysis CKD has not been clearly established. The aim of this study was to assess the frequency of RLS in non-dialysis CKD patients (stages 2 to 4) followed in a reference nephrology outpatient clinic.

Methods: A standardized questionnaire following the international RLS study group diagnostic criteria was self-administered by 110 patients regularly followed in the nephrology clinic. The series comprised 69 men and 41 women, aged 68 ± 13.2 years, with mean serum creatinine of 1.7 ± 0.8 mg/dL. Subsequently, patients classified as probable RLS according to the questionnaire underwent a systematic neurological examination. The presence of peripheral artery disease was evaluated by the ankle-brachial index (ABI).

Results: The frequency of probable RLS according to the questionnaire results was 21% (17% for men and 27% for women). However, after thorough neurological examination, the diagnosis of RLS was confirmed in only 5 patients. Therefore, the overall definitive RLS frequency was 4.5% (within the prevalence reported for the general population) and was higher among women (9.7% vs 0.2%). In the remaining cases symptoms were due to leg discomfort related with other disorders. Patients with probable and improbable RLS were not significantly different in age, ABI, diabetes, and other comorbid circumstances, except for tricyclic antidepressant prescription, which was more frequent in the probable RLS group (17% vs 2%). Renal function was better in definitive RLS patients than cases classified as probable RLS by the questionnaire but not confirmed after neurological exam.

Conclusions: Although RLS can represent an early manifestation of CKD, its prevalence seems very close to that reported for the general population. Diagnostic confirmation of RLS dramatically falls after expert examination, raising the question whether, in the study of RLS cohorts, CKD has a potentially causal relationship or is a confounding factor associated with other causes of leg discomfort.

Keywords: IRLSSG questionnaire; RLS mimics; chronic renal failure; prevalence; restless legs syndrome.