Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
. 2015 Mar 6;114(9):092003.
doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.092003. Epub 2015 Mar 4.

Study of e(+)e(-)→ωχ(cJ) at center of mass energies from 4.21 to 4.42 GeV

M Ablikim  1 M N Achasov  2 X C Ai  1 O Albayrak  3 M Albrecht  4 D J Ambrose  5 A Amoroso  6   7 F F An  1 Q An  8 J Z Bai  1 R Baldini Ferroli  9 Y Ban  10 D W Bennett  11 J V Bennett  3 M Bertani  9 D Bettoni  12 J M Bian  13 F Bianchi  6   7 E Boger  14 O Bondarenko  15 I Boyko  14 R A Briere  3 H Cai  16 X Cai  1 O Cakir  17 A Calcaterra  9 G F Cao  1 S A Cetin  18 J F Chang  1 G Chelkov  14 G Chen  1 H S Chen  1 H Y Chen  19 J C Chen  1 M L Chen  1 S J Chen  20 X Chen  1 X R Chen  21 Y B Chen  1 H P Cheng  22 X K Chu  10 Y P Chu  1 G Cibinetto  12 D Cronin-Hennessy  13 H L Dai  1 J P Dai  1 D Dedovich  14 Z Y Deng  1 A Denig  23 I Denysenko  14 M Destefanis  6   7 F De Mori  6   7 Y Ding  24 C Dong  25 J Dong  1 L Y Dong  1 M Y Dong  1 S X Du  26 P F Duan  1 J Z Fan  27 J Fang  1 S S Fang  1 X Fang  8 Y Fang  1 L Fava  28   7 F Feldbauer  23 G Felici  9 C Q Feng  8 E Fioravanti  12 C D Fu  1 Q Gao  1 Y Gao  27 I Garzia  12 K Goetzen  29 W X Gong  1 W Gradl  23 M Greco  6   7 M H Gu  1 Y T Gu  30 Y H Guan  1 A Q Guo  1 L B Guo  31 T Guo  31 Y Guo  1 Y P Guo  23 Z Haddadi  15 A Hafner  23 S Han  16 Y L Han  1 F A Harris  32 K L He  1 Z Y He  25 T Held  4 Y K Heng  1 Z L Hou  1 C Hu  31 H M Hu  1 J F Hu  6 T Hu  1 Y Hu  1 G M Huang  33 G S Huang  8 H P Huang  16 J S Huang  34 X T Huang  35 Y Huang  20 T Hussain  36 Q Ji  1 Q P Ji  25 X B Ji  1 X L Ji  1 L L Jiang  1 L W Jiang  16 X S Jiang  1 J B Jiao  35 Z Jiao  22 D P Jin  1 S Jin  1 T Johansson  37 A Julin  13 N Kalantar-Nayestanaki  15 X L Kang  1 X S Kang  25 M Kavatsyuk  15 B C Ke  3 R Kliemt  38 B Kloss  23 O B Kolcu  18 B Kopf  4 M Kornicer  32 W Kuehn  39 A Kupsc  37 W Lai  1 J S Lange  39 M Lara  11 P Larin  38 Cheng Li  8 C H Li  1 D M Li  26 F Li  1 G Li  1 H B Li  1 J C Li  1 Jin Li  40 K Li  41 K Li  35 P R Li  42 T Li  35 W D Li  1 W G Li  1 X L Li  35 X M Li  30 X N Li  1 X Q Li  25 Z B Li  43 H Liang  8 Y F Liang  44 Y T Liang  39 G R Liao  45 D X Lin  38 B J Liu  1 C L Liu  3 C X Liu  1 F H Liu  46 Fang Liu  1 Feng Liu  33 H B Liu  30 H H Liu  1 H H Liu  47 H M Liu  1 J Liu  1 J P Liu  16 J Y Liu  1 K Liu  27 K Y Liu  24 L D Liu  10 Q Liu  42 S B Liu  8 X Liu  21 X X Liu  42 Y B Liu  25 Z A Liu  1 Zhiqiang Liu  1 Zhiqing Liu  23 H Loehner  15 X C Lou  1 H J Lu  22 J G Lu  1 R Q Lu  48 Y Lu  1 Y P Lu  1 C L Luo  31 M X Luo  49 T Luo  32 X L Luo  1 M Lv  1 X R Lyu  42 F C Ma  24 H L Ma  1 L L Ma  35 Q M Ma  1 S Ma  1 T Ma  1 X N Ma  25 X Y Ma  1 F E Maas  38 M Maggiora  6   7 Q A Malik  36 Y J Mao  10 Z P Mao  1 S Marcello  6   7 J G Messchendorp  15 J Min  1 T J Min  1 R E Mitchell  11 X H Mo  1 Y J Mo  33 H Moeini  15 C Morales Morales  38 K Moriya  11 N Yu Muchnoi  2 H Muramatsu  13 Y Nefedov  14 F Nerling  38 I B Nikolaev  2 Z Ning  1 S Nisar  50 S L Niu  1 X Y Niu  1 S L Olsen  40 Q Ouyang  1 S Pacetti  51 P Patteri  9 M Pelizaeus  4 H P Peng  8 K Peters  29 J L Ping  31 R G Ping  1 R Poling  13 Y N Pu  48 M Qi  20 S Qian  1 C F Qiao  42 L Q Qin  35 N Qin  16 X S Qin  1 Y Qin  10 Z H Qin  1 J F Qiu  1 K H Rashid  36 C F Redmer  23 H L Ren  48 M Ripka  23 G Rong  1 X D Ruan  30 V Santoro  12 A Sarantsev  14 M Savrié  52 K Schoenning  37 S Schumann  23 W Shan  10 M Shao  8 C P Shen  19 P X Shen  25 X Y Shen  1 H Y Sheng  1 M R Shepherd  11 W M Song  1 X Y Song  1 S Sosio  6   7 S Spataro  6   7 B Spruck  39 G X Sun  1 J F Sun  34 S S Sun  1 Y J Sun  8 Y Z Sun  1 Z J Sun  1 Z T Sun  11 C J Tang  44 X Tang  1 I Tapan  53 E H Thorndike  5 M Tiemens  15 D Toth  13 M Ullrich  39 I Uman  18 G S Varner  32 B Wang  25 B L Wang  42 D Wang  10 D Y Wang  10 K Wang  1 L L Wang  1 L S Wang  1 M Wang  35 P Wang  1 P L Wang  1 Q J Wang  1 S G Wang  10 W Wang  1 X F Wang  27 Y D Wang  9 Y F Wang  1 Y Q Wang  23 Z Wang  1 Z G Wang  1 Z H Wang  8 Z Y Wang  1 D H Wei  45 J B Wei  10 P Weidenkaff  23 S P Wen  1 U Wiedner  4 M Wolke  37 L H Wu  1 Z Wu  1 L G Xia  27 Y Xia  48 D Xiao  1 Z J Xiao  31 Y G Xie  1 Q L Xiu  1 G F Xu  1 L Xu  1 Q J Xu  41 Q N Xu  42 X P Xu  54 L Yan  8 W B Yan  8 W C Yan  8 Y H Yan  48 H X Yang  1 L Yang  16 Y Yang  33 Y X Yang  45 H Ye  1 M Ye  1 M H Ye  55 J H Yin  1 B X Yu  1 C X Yu  25 H W Yu  10 J S Yu  21 C Z Yuan  1 W L Yuan  20 Y Yuan  1 A Yuncu  18 A A Zafar  36 A Zallo  9 Y Zeng  48 B X Zhang  1 B Y Zhang  1 C Zhang  20 C C Zhang  1 D H Zhang  1 H H Zhang  43 H Y Zhang  1 J J Zhang  1 J L Zhang  1 J Q Zhang  1 J W Zhang  1 J Y Zhang  1 J Z Zhang  1 K Zhang  1 L Zhang  1 S H Zhang  1 X J Zhang  1 X Y Zhang  35 Y Zhang  1 Y H Zhang  1 Z H Zhang  33 Z P Zhang  8 Z Y Zhang  16 G Zhao  1 J W Zhao  1 J Y Zhao  1 J Z Zhao  1 Lei Zhao  8 Ling Zhao  1 M G Zhao  25 Q Zhao  1 Q W Zhao  1 S J Zhao  26 T C Zhao  1 Y B Zhao  1 Z G Zhao  8 A Zhemchugov  14 B Zheng  56 J P Zheng  1 W J Zheng  35 Y H Zheng  42 B Zhong  31 L Zhou  1 Li Zhou  25 X Zhou  16 X K Zhou  8 X R Zhou  8 X Y Zhou  1 K Zhu  1 K J Zhu  1 S Zhu  1 X L Zhu  27 Y C Zhu  8 Y S Zhu  1 Z A Zhu  1 J Zhuang  1 B S Zou  1 J H Zou  1 (BESIII Collaboration)
Affiliations
Free article

Study of e(+)e(-)→ωχ(cJ) at center of mass energies from 4.21 to 4.42 GeV

M Ablikim et al. Phys Rev Lett. .
Free article

Abstract

Based on data samples collected with the BESIII detector at the BEPCII collider at nine center of mass energies from 4.21 to 4.42 GeV, we search for the production of e^{+}e^{-}→ωχ_{cJ} (J=0, 1, 2). The process e^{+}e^{-}→ωχ_{c0} is observed for the first time, and the Born cross sections at sqrt[s]=4.23 and 4.26 GeV are measured to be (55.4±6.0±5.9) and (23.7±5.3±3.5) pb, respectively, where the first uncertainties are statistical and the second are systematic. The ωχ_{c0} signals at the other seven energies and the e^{+}e^{-}→ωχ_{c1} and ωχ_{c2} signals are not significant, and the upper limits on the cross sections are determined. By examining the ωχ_{c0} cross section as a function of center of mass energy, we find that it is inconsistent with the line shape of the Y(4260) observed in e^{+}e^{-}→π^{+}π^{-}J/ψ. Assuming the ωχ_{c0} signals come from a single resonance, we extract the mass and width of the resonance to be (4230±8±6) MeV/c^{2} and (38±12±2) MeV, respectively, and the statistical significance is more than 9σ.

PubMed Disclaimer

Similar articles

  • Observation of Structures in the Processes e^{+}e^{-}→ωχ_{c1} and ωχ_{c2}.
    Ablikim M, Achasov MN, Adlarson P, Ai XC, Aliberti R, Amoroso A, An MR, An Q, Bai Y, Bakina O, Balossino I, Ban Y, Bao HR, Batozskaya V, Begzsuren K, Berger N, Berlowski M, Bertani M, Bettoni D, Bianchi F, Bianco E, Bortone A, Boyko I, Briere RA, Brueggemann A, Cai H, Cai X, Calcaterra A, Cao GF, Cao N, Cetin SA, Chang JF, Chang TT, Chang WL, Che GR, Chelkov G, Chen C, Chen C, Chen G, Chen HS, Chen ML, Chen SJ, Chen SL, Chen SM, Chen T, Chen XR, Chen XT, Chen YB, Chen YQ, Chen ZJ, Cheng WS, Choi SK, Chu X, Cibinetto G, Coen SC, Cossio F, Cui JJ, Dai HL, Dai JP, Dbeyssi A, de Boer RE, Dedovich D, Deng ZY, Denig A, Denysenko I, Destefanis M, De Mori F, Ding B, Ding XX, Ding Y, Ding Y, Dong J, Dong LY, Dong MY, Dong X, Du MC, Du SX, Duan ZH, Egorov P, Fan YH, Fang J, Fang SS, Fang WX, Fang Y, Farinelli R, Fava L, Feldbauer F, Felici G, Feng CQ, Feng JH, Fischer K, Fritsch M, Fu CD, Fu JL, Fu YW, Gao H, Gao YN, Gao Y, Garbolino S, Garzia I, Ge PT, Ge ZW, Geng C, Gersabeck EM, Gilman A, Goetzen K, Gong L, Gong WX, Gradl W, Gramigna S, Greco M, Gu MH, Gu YT, Guan CY, Guan ZL, Guo AQ, Guo LB, Guo MJ, Guo RP, Guo YP, Guskov A, Han TT, Han WY, Hao XQ, Harris FA, He KK, He KL, Heinsius FHH,… See abstract for full author list ➔ Ablikim M, et al. Phys Rev Lett. 2024 Apr 19;132(16):161901. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.161901. Phys Rev Lett. 2024. PMID: 38701481
  • Observation of a charged charmoniumlike structure in e+ e- → π+ π- J/ψ at sqrt[s] = 4.26  GeV.
    Ablikim M, Achasov MN, Ai XC, Albayrak O, Ambrose DJ, An FF, An Q, Bai JZ, Baldini Ferroli R, Ban Y, Becker J, Bennett JV, Bertani M, Bian JM, Boger E, Bondarenko O, Boyko I, Briere RA, Bytev V, Cai H, Cai X, Cakir O, Calcaterra A, Cao GF, Cetin SA, Chang JF, Chelkov G, Chen G, Chen HS, Chen JC, Chen ML, Chen SJ, Chen X, Chen YB, Cheng HP, Chu YP, Cronin-Hennessy D, Dai HL, Dai JP, Dedovich D, Deng ZY, Denig A, Denysenko I, Destefanis M, Ding WM, Ding Y, Dong LY, Dong MY, Du SX, Fang J, Fang SS, Fava L, Feng CQ, Friedel P, Fu CD, Fu JL, Fuks O, Gao Q, Gao Y, Geng C, Goetzen K, Gong WX, Gradl W, Greco M, Gu MH, Gu YT, Guan YH, Guo AQ, Guo LB, Guo T, Guo YP, Han YL, Harris FA, He KL, He M, He ZY, Held T, Heng YK, Hou ZL, Hu C, Hu HM, Hu JF, Hu T, Huang GM, Huang GS, Huang JS, Huang L, Huang XT, Huang Y, Huang YP, Hussain T, Ji CS, Ji Q, Ji QP, Ji XB, Ji XL, Jiang LL, Jiang XS, Jiao JB, Jiao Z, Jin DP, Jin S, Jing FF, Kalantar-Nayestanaki N, Kavatsyuk M, Kopf B, Kornicer M, Kühn W, Lai W, Lange JS, Lara M, Larin P, Leyhe M, Li CH, Li C, Li C, Li DM, Li F, Li G, Li HB, Li JC, Li K, Li L, Li QJ, Li SL, Li WD, Li WG, Li XL, Li XN, Li XQ, Li XR, Li ZB, Liang H, Liang YF, Liang YT, Liao G… See abstract for full author list ➔ Ablikim M, et al. Phys Rev Lett. 2013 Jun 21;110(25):252001. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.110.252001. Epub 2013 Jun 17. Phys Rev Lett. 2013. PMID: 23829729
  • Observation of the ψ(1 3D2) State in e+e-→π+π-γχc1 at BESIII.
    Ablikim M, Achasov MN, Ai XC, Albayrak O, Albrecht M, Ambrose DJ, Amoroso A, An FF, An Q, Bai JZ, Baldini Ferroli R, Ban Y, Bennett DW, Bennett JV, Bertani M, Bettoni D, Bian JM, Bianchi F, Boger E, Bondarenko O, Boyko I, Briere RA, Cai H, Cai X, Cakir O, Calcaterra A, Cao GF, Cetin SA, Chang JF, Chelkov G, Chen G, Chen HS, Chen HY, Chen JC, Chen ML, Chen SJ, Chen X, Chen XR, Chen YB, Cheng HP, Chu XK, Cibinetto G, Cronin-Hennessy D, Dai HL, Dai JP, Dbeyssi A, Dedovich D, Deng ZY, Denig A, Denysenko I, Destefanis M, De Mori F, Ding Y, Dong C, Dong J, Dong LY, Dong MY, Du SX, Duan PF, Fan JZ, Fang J, Fang SS, Fang X, Fang Y, Fava L, Feldbauer F, Felici G, Feng CQ, Fioravanti E, Fritsch M, Fu CD, Gao Q, Gao Y, Gao Z, Garzia I, Geng C, Goetzen K, Gong WX, Gradl W, Greco M, Gu MH, Gu YT, Guan YH, Guo AQ, Guo LB, Guo Y, Guo YP, Haddadi Z, Hafner A, Han S, Han YL, Hao XQ, Harris FA, He KL, He ZY, Held T, Heng YK, Hou ZL, Hu C, Hu HM, Hu JF, Hu T, Hu Y, Huang GM, Huang GS, Huang HP, Huang JS, Huang XT, Huang Y, Hussain T, Ji Q, Ji QP, Ji XB, Ji XL, Jiang LL, Jiang LW, Jiang XS, Jiao JB, Jiao Z, Jin DP, Jin S, Johansson T, Julin A, Kalantar-Nayestanaki N, Kang XL, Kang XS, Kavatsyuk M, Ke… See abstract for full author list ➔ Ablikim M, et al. Phys Rev Lett. 2015 Jul 3;115(1):011803. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.011803. Epub 2015 Jul 1. Phys Rev Lett. 2015. PMID: 26182091
  • Observation of e^{+}e^{-}→ωχ_{bJ}(1P) and Search for X_{b}→ωϒ(1S) at sqrt[s] near 10.75 GeV.
    Adachi I, Aggarwal L, Ahmed H, Aihara H, Akopov N, Aloisio A, Anh Ky N, Asner DM, Aushev T, Aushev V, Bae H, Bambade P, Banerjee S, Baudot J, Bauer M, Beaubien A, Becker J, Behera PK, Bennett JV, Bernieri E, Bernlochner FU, Bertacchi V, Bertemes M, Bertholet E, Bessner M, Bettarini S, Bhuyan B, Bianchi F, Bilka T, Biswas D, Bodrov D, Bolz A, Borah J, Bozek A, Bračko M, Branchini P, Browder TE, Budano A, Bussino S, Campajola M, Cao L, Casarosa G, Chang MC, Cheema P, Chekelian V, Chen YQ, Chilikin K, Chirapatpimol K, Cho HE, Cho K, Cho SJ, Choi SK, Choudhury S, Cinabro D, Corona L, Cunliffe S, Das S, Dattola F, De La Cruz-Burelo E, De La Motte SA, De Nardo G, De Nuccio M, De Pietro G, de Sangro R, Destefanis M, Dey S, De Yta-Hernandez A, Dhamija R, Di Canto A, Di Capua F, Doležal Z, Domínguez Jiménez I, Dong TV, Dorigo M, Dort K, Dreyer S, Dubey S, Dujany G, Eliachevitch M, Feichtinger P, Ferber T, Ferlewicz D, Fillinger T, Finocchiaro G, Fodor A, Forti F, Fulsom BG, Ganiev E, Gaur V, Gaz A, Gellrich A, Ghevondyan G, Giordano R, Giri A, Glazov A, Gobbo B, Godang R, Goldenzweig P, Granderath S, Graziani E, Greenwald D, Gu T, Guan Y, Gudkova K, Guilliams J, Hara T, Hayasaka K, Hayashi… See abstract for full author list ➔ Adachi I, et al. Phys Rev Lett. 2023 Mar 3;130(9):091902. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.130.091902. Phys Rev Lett. 2023. PMID: 36930912
  • Observation of a charged charmoniumlike structure Zc(4020) and search for the Zc(3900) in e+e-→π+π-hc.
    Ablikim M, Achasov MN, Albayrak O, Ambrose DJ, An FF, An Q, Bai JZ, Baldini Ferroli R, Ban Y, Becker J, Bennett JV, Bertani M, Bian JM, Boger E, Bondarenko O, Boyko I, Braun S, Briere RA, Bytev V, Cai H, Cai X, Cakir O, Calcaterra A, Cao GF, Cetin SA, Chang JF, Chelkov G, Chen G, Chen HS, Chen JC, Chen ML, Chen SJ, Chen XR, Chen YB, Cheng HP, Chu XK, Chu YP, Cronin-Hennessy D, Dai HL, Dai JP, Dedovich D, Deng ZY, Denig A, Denysenko I, Destefanis M, Ding WM, Ding Y, Dong LY, Dong MY, Du SX, Fang J, Fang SS, Fava L, Feng CQ, Friedel P, Fu CD, Fu JL, Fuks O, Gao Y, Geng C, Goetzen K, Gong WX, Gradl W, Greco M, Gu MH, Gu YT, Guan YH, Guo AQ, Guo LB, Guo T, Guo YP, Han YL, Harris FA, He KL, He M, He ZY, Held T, Heng YK, Hou ZL, Hu C, Hu HM, Hu JF, Hu T, Huang GM, Huang GS, Huang JS, Huang L, Huang XT, Huang Y, Hussain T, Ji CS, Ji Q, Ji QP, Ji XB, Ji XL, Jiang LL, Jiang XS, Jiao JB, Jiao Z, Jin DP, Jin S, Jing FF, Kalantar-Nayestanaki N, Kavatsyuk M, Kloss B, Kopf B, Kornicer M, Kuehn W, Lai W, Lange JS, Lara M, Larin P, Leyhe M, Li CH, Li C, Li C, Li DL, Li DM, Li F, Li G, Li HB, Li JC, Li K, Li L, Li N, Li PR, Li QJ, Li WD, Li WG, Li XL, Li XN, Li XQ, Li XR, Li ZB, Liang H, Liang YF,… See abstract for full author list ➔ Ablikim M, et al. Phys Rev Lett. 2013 Dec 13;111(24):242001. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.242001. Epub 2013 Dec 10. Phys Rev Lett. 2013. PMID: 24483645

Cited by