Dressings for treating foot ulcers in people with diabetes: an overview of systematic reviews
- PMID: 26171906
- PMCID: PMC7083265
- DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD010471.pub2
Dressings for treating foot ulcers in people with diabetes: an overview of systematic reviews
Abstract
Background: Foot ulcers in people with diabetes mellitus are a common and serious global health issue. Dressings form a key part of ulcer treatment, with clinicians and patients having many different types to choose from. A clear and current overview of current evidence is required to facilitate decision-making regarding dressing use.
Objectives: To summarize data from systematic reviews of randomised controlled trial evidence on the effectiveness of dressings for healing foot ulcers in people with diabetes mellitus (DM).
Methods: We searched the following databases for relevant systematic reviews and associated analyses: the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL; The Cochrane Library 2015, Issue 2); Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects (DARE; The Cochrane Library 2015, Issue 1); Ovid MEDLINE (In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, 14 April 2015); Ovid EMBASE (1980 to 14 April 2015). We also handsearched the Cochrane Wounds Group list of reviews. Two review authors independently performed study selection, risk of bias assessment and data extraction. Complete wound healing was the primary outcome assessed; secondary outcomes included health-related quality of life, adverse events, resource use and dressing performance.
Main results: We found 13 eligible systematic reviews relevant to this overview that contained a total of 17 relevant RCTs. One review reported the results of a network meta-analysis and so presented information on indirect, as well as direct, treatment effects. Collectively the reviews reported findings for 11 different comparisons supported by direct data and 26 comparisons supported by indirect data only. Only four comparisons informed by direct data found evidence of a difference in wound healing between dressing types, but the evidence was assessed as being of low or very low quality (in one case data could not be located and checked). There was also no robust evidence of a difference between dressing types for any secondary outcomes assessed.
Authors' conclusions: There is currently no robust evidence for differences between wound dressings for any outcome in foot ulcers in people with diabetes (treated in any setting). Practitioners may want to consider the unit cost of dressings, their management properties and patient preference when choosing dressings.
Conflict of interest statement
Jo Dumville: none to declare. Gill Norman: none to declare. Susan O'Meara: none to declare. Sally Bell‐Syer: none to declare. Lihua Wu: none to declare.
Update of
- doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010471
References
References to included reviews
Dumville 2012
Dumville 2013a
Dumville 2013b
Dumville 2013c
Dumville 2013d
Edwards 2010
Game 2012
-
- Game FL, Hinchliffe RJ, Appleqvist J, Armstrong DG, Bakker K, Hartemann A, et al. A systematic review of interventions to enhance the healing of chronic ulcers of the foot in diabetes. Diabetes/Metabolism Research and Reviews 2012;28 (Supp 1):119–41. - PubMed
Hinchliffe 2008b
-
- Hinchliffe R, Valk GD, Apelqvist J, Armstrong DG, Bakker K, Game FL, et al. A systematic review of the effectiveness of interventions to enhance the healing of chronic ulcers of the foot in diabetes. Diabetes Metabolism Research Review 2008;24(Suppl 1):S119‐44. - PubMed
Mason 1999a
-
- Mason J, O'Keeffe C, Hutchinson A, McIntosh A, Young R, Booth A. A systematic review of foot ulcer in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. II: Treatment. Diabetes Medicine 1999;16(11):889‐909. - PubMed
Nelson 2006
-
- Nelson EA, O'Meara S, Golder S, Dalton J, Craig D, Iglesias C, DASIDU Steering Group. Systematic review of antimicrobial treatments for diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetic Medicine 2006;23:348‐59. - PubMed
O'Meara 2000
-
- Meara S, Cullum N, Majid M, Sheldon T. Systematic reviews of wound care management: (3) antimicrobial agents for chronic wounds; (4) diabetic foot ulceration. Health Technology Assessment 2000;4(21):1‐237. - PubMed
Storm‐Versloot 2010
Voigt 2012
-
- Voigt J, Driver VR. Hyaluronic acid derivatives and their healing effect on burns, epithelial surgical wounds, and chronic wounds: a systematic review and meta‐analysis of randomized controlled trials. Wound Repair and Regeneration 2012;20:317‐31. - PubMed
References to excluded reviews
Ashton 2004
-
- Ashton J. Managing leg and foot ulcers: the role of Kerraboot. British Journal of Community Nursing 2004;9:S26‐30. - PubMed
Bergin 2006
Bradley 1999
-
- Bradley M, Cullum N, Sheldon T. The debridement of chronic wounds: a systematic review. Health Technology Assessment 1999;3:iii‐73. - PubMed
Braun 2014
-
- Braun LR, Fisk WA, Lev‐Tov H, Kirsner RS, Isseroff RR. Diabetic foot ulcer: an evidence‐based treatment update. American Journal of Clinical Dermatology 2014;15:267‐81. - PubMed
Brimson 2013
-
- Brimson CH, Nigam Y. The role of oxygen‐associated therapies for the healing of chronic wounds, particularly in patients with diabetes. Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology 2013;27:411‐8. - PubMed
Eddy 2008
-
- Eddy JJ, Gideonsen MD, Mack GP. Practical considerations of using topical honey for neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers: a review. Wisconsin Medical Journal 2008;107:187‐90. - PubMed
Greer 2013
-
- Greer N, Foman NA, MacDonald R, Dorrian J, Fitzgerald P, Rutks I, et al. Advanced wound care therapies for nonhealing diabetic, venous, and arterial ulcers: a systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine 2013;159:532‐42. - PubMed
Heyer 2013
-
- Heyer K, Augustin M, Protz K, Herberger K, Spehr C, Rustenbach SJ. Effectiveness of advanced versus conventional wound dressings on healing of chronic wounds: systematic review and meta‐analysis. Dermatology 2013;226:172‐84. - PubMed
Holmes 2013
Jones 2009
-
- Jones KR. Wound healing in older adults. Aging Health 2009;5:851‐66.
Jull 2013
Vandamme 2013
-
- Vandamme L, Heyneman A, Hoeksema H, Verbelen J, Monstrey S. Honey in modern wound care: a systematic review.. Burns 2013;39:1514‐25. - PubMed
Wang 2005
-
- Wang R‐X, Song Z‐Q. Application of evidence based medicine for diabetic foot. Chinese Journal of Clinical Rehabilitation 2005;9:138‐40.
Additional references
Abbott 2002
-
- Abbott CA, Carrington AL, Ashe H, Bath S, Every LC, Griffiths J, et al. The North West Diabetes Foot Care Study: incidence of and risk factors for, new diabetic foot ulceration in a community‐based patient cohort. Diabetic Medicine 2002;19:377‐84. - PubMed
Ahroni 1993
-
- Ahroni JH, Boyko EJ, Pecoraro RE. Diabetic foot ulcer healing: extrinsic vs intrinsic factors. Wounds 1993;5(5):245‐55.
Apelqvist 2000a
-
- Apelqvist J, Bakker K, Houtum WH, Nabuurs‐Franssen MH, Schaper NC. International consensus and practical guidelines on the management and the prevention of the diabetic foot: International Working Group on the Diabetic Foot. Diabetes Metabolism Research and Review 2000;16(Supp 1):S84‐92. - PubMed
Apelqvist 2000b
-
- Apelqvist J, Larsson J. What is the most effective way to reduce incidence of amputation in the diabetic foot?. Diabetes Metabolism Research and Reviews 2000;16(Suppl 1):S75‐83. - PubMed
Atkins 2004
Baker 1993
-
- Baker NR, Creevy J. A randomised comparative pilot study to evaluate Allevyn hydrocellular dressings and Sorbsan calcium‐alginate dressings in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. Unpublished 1993.
Becker 2011
-
- Becker LA, Oxman AD. Chapter 22: Overviews of reviews. In: Higgins JPT, Green S (editors), Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 (updated March 2011). The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from www.cochrane‐handbook.org.
Blackman 1994
-
- Blackman JD, Senseng D, Quinn L, Mazzone T. Clinical evaluation of a semipermeable polymeric membrane dressing for the treatment of chronic diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetic Care 1994;17(4):322‐5. - PubMed
BNF 2014
-
- British Medical Association and Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain. British National Formulary Appendix 8: Wound management products and elastic hosiery. http://www.bnf.org.uk/bnf/bnf/current Nov 2014;68. Accessed November 2014.
Boateng 2008
-
- Boateng JS, Matthews KH, Stevens HNE, Eccleston GM. Wound healing dressings and drug delivery systems: a review. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 2008;97(8):2892‐923. - PubMed
Cardinal 2009
-
- Cardinal M, Eisenbud DE, Armstrong DG, Zelen C, Driver V, Attinger C, et al. Serial surgical debridement: a retrospective study on clinical outcomes in chronic lower extremity wounds. Wound Repair and Regeneration 2009;17(3):306‐11. - PubMed
Clever 1995
-
- Clever HU, Dreyer M. Comparing two wound dressings for the treatment of neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers. Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Advances in Wound Management; 1995 November 21‐24 ; Harrogate, UK. Harrogate, UK, 1995:201‐3.
D'Hemecourt 1998
-
- D'Hemecourt PA, Smiell JM, Karim MR. Sodium carboxymethyl cellulose aqueous‐based gel vs becaplermin gel in patients with nonhealing lower extremity diabetic ulcers. Wounds 1998;10(3):69‐75.
Dolan 1995
-
- Dolan P, Gudex C, Kind P, Williams A. A social tariff for EuroQol: results from a UK general population survey. University of York Centre for Health Economics Discussion Paper Series (no 138) 1995.
Donaghue 1998
-
- Donaghue VM, Chrzan JS, Rosenblum BI, Giurini JM, Habershaw GM, Veves A. Evaluation of a collagen‐alginate wound dressing in the management of diabetic foot ulcers. Advances in Wound Care 1998;11(3):114‐9. - PubMed
Dorresteijn 2010
Edmonds 2000
-
- Edmonds M, Foster A. Hyalofill: a new product for chronic wound management. Diabetic Foot 2000;3:29‐30.
Fiskin 1996
-
- Fiskin R, Digby M. Which dressing for diabetic foot ulcers?. Practical Diabetes International 1996;13(4):107‐9.
Foster 1994
-
- Foster AVM, Greenhill MT, Edmonds ME. Comparing two dressings in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. Journal of Wound Care 1994;3(5):224‐8. - PubMed
Higgins 2011
-
- Higgins JPT, Green S (editors). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from www.cochrane‐handbook.org.
Hinchliffe 2008a
-
- Hinchliffe R, Valk GD, Apelqvist J, Armstrong DG, Bakker K, Game FL, et al. A systematic review of the effectiveness of interventions to enhance the healing of chronic ulcers of the foot in diabetes. Diabetes Metabolism Research Review 2008;24(Suppl 1):S119‐44. - PubMed
Ince 2008
-
- Ince P, Abbas ZG, Lutale JK, Basit A, Ali SM, Chohan F, et al. Use of the SINBAD classification system and score in comparing outcome of foot ulcer management on three continents. Diabetes Care 2008;31(5):964‐7. - PubMed
Jadad 1996
-
- Jadad AR, Moore RA, Carroll D, Jenkinson C, Reynolds DJ, Gavaghan DJ, et al. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary?. Controlled Clinical Trials 1996;17(1):1‐12. - PubMed
Jeffcoate 2009
-
- Jeffcoate WJ, Price PE, Phillips CJ, Game FL, Mudge E, Davies S. Randomised controlled trial of the use of three dressing preparations in the management of chronic ulceration of the foot in diabetes. Health Technology Assessment 2009;13(54):1‐110. - PubMed
Jensen 1998
-
- Jensen JL, Seeley J, Gillin B. A controlled, randomized comparison of two moist wound healing protocols: Carrasyn hydrogel wound dressing and wet‐to‐moist saline gauze. Advances in Wound Care 1998;11(7 Suppl 1):1‐4. - PubMed
Jude 2007
-
- Jude EB, Apelqvist J, Spraul M, Martini J. Prospective randomized controlled study of Hydrofiber dressing containing ionic silver or calcium alginate dressings in non‐ischaemic diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetic Medicine 2007;24(3):280‐8. - PubMed
Karthikesalingam 2010
-
- Karthikesalingam A, Holt PJE, Moxey P, Jones KG, Thompson MM, Hinchliffe RJ. A systematic review of scoring systems for diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetic Medicine 2010;27(5):544‐9. - PubMed
Kumar 1994
-
- Kumar S, Ashe HA, Parnell LN, Fernando DJ, Tsigos C, Young RJ, et al. The prevalence of foot ulceration and its correlates in type 2 diabetic patients: a population‐based study. Diabetic Medicine 1994;11(5):480‐4. - PubMed
Lalau 2002
-
- Lalau JD, Bresson R, Charpentier P, Coliche V, Erlher S, Ha Van G, et al. Efficacy and tolerance of calcium alginate versus Vaseline gauze dressings in the treatment of diabetic foot lesions. Diabetes and Metabolism 2002;28(3):223‐9. - PubMed
Leeds Community Healthcare 2011
-
- NHS Leeds Community Healthcare (LCH) Community Tissue Viability Service. How to choose the correct dressing. Local guideline (supplied via personal communication) February 2011:1‐12.
Lewis 2013
Margolis 1999
-
- Margolis D, Kantor J, Berlin J. Healing of diabetic neuropathic foot ulcers receiving standard treatment. A meta‐analysis. Diabetes Care 1999;22(5):692‐5. - PubMed
Margolis 2011
-
- Margolis D, Malay DS, Hoffstad OJ, Leonard CE, MaCurdy T, López de Nava K, et al. Prevalence of diabetes, diabetic foot ulcer, and lower extremity amputation among Medicare beneficiaries, 2006 to 2008. Data Points #1. Prepared by the University of Pennsylvania DEcIDE Center, under Contract No. HHSA29020050041I). Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality January 2011; Vol. AHRQ Publication No. 10(11)‐EHC009‐EF. - PubMed
Mason 1999
-
- Mason J, O'Keeffe C, Hutchinson A, McIntosh A, Young R, Booth A. A systematic review of foot ulcer in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. II: Treatment. Diabetes Medicine 1999;16(11):889‐909. - PubMed
Mazzone 1993
-
- Mazzone T, Blackman JD. Evaluation of a new loaded foam membrane on the healing rate of diabetic foot ulcers. 1st Joint Meeting of the Wound Healing Society and the European Tissue Repair Society; 1993, August 22‐25; Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1993.
Morris 1998
-
- Morris AD, McAlpine R, Steinke D, Boyle DI, Ebrahim AR, Vasudev N, et al. Diabetes and lower limb amputations in the community. A retrospective cohort study. DARTS/MEMO Collaboration. Diabetes Audit and Research in Tayside Scotland/Medicines Monitoring Unit. Diabetes Care 1998;21(5):738‐43. - PubMed
Nabuurs‐Franssen 2005
-
- Nabuurs‐Franssen MH, Huijberts MS, Nieuwenhuijzen Kruseman AC, Willems J, Schaper NC. Health‐related quality of life of diabetic foot ulcer patients and their caregivers. Diabetologia 2005;48(9):1906‐10. - PubMed
NICE 2013
-
- National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. Diabetic foot problems: Evidence update March 2013. Available from https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance. 2013; Vol. Evidence Update 33. Accessed November 2014.
Oyibo 2001
-
- Oyibo SO, Jude EB, Tarawneh I, Nguyen HC, Harkless LB, Boulton AJ. A comparison of two diabetic foot ulcer classification systems: the Wagner and the University of Texas wound classification systems. Diabetes Care 2001;24(1):84‐8. - PubMed
Pecoraro 1990
-
- Pecoraro RE, Reiber GE, Burgess EM. Pathways to diabetic limb amputation: basis for prevention. Diabetes Care 1990;13(5):513‐21. - PubMed
Piaggesi 2001
-
- Piaggesi A, Baccetti F, Rizzo L, Romanelli, Navalesi R, Benzi L. Sodium carboxyl‐methyl‐cellulose dressings in the management of deep ulcerations of diabetic foot. Diabetic Medicine 2001;18(4):320‐4. - PubMed
Pound 2005
-
- Pound N, Chipchase S, Treece K, Game F, Jeffcoate W. Ulcer‐free survival following management of foot ulcers in diabetes. Diabetic Medicine 2005;22(10):1306‐9. - PubMed
Price 2004
Reiber 1996
-
- Reiber G. The epidemiology of diabetic foot problems. Diabetic Medicine 1996;13S:S6‐11. - PubMed
Reiber 1999
-
- Reiber GE, Vileikyte L, Boyko EJ, Aguila M, Smith DG, Lavery LA, et al. Causal pathways for incident lower extremity ulcers in patients with diabetes from two settings. Diabetes Care 1999;22:157‐62. - PubMed
RevMan 2014 [Computer program]
-
- The Nordic Cochrane Centre. Review Manager (RevMan) Version 5.3. Copenhagen: The Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration 2014.
Ribu 2006
-
- Ribu L, Hanestad BR, Moum T, Birkeland K, Rustoen T. A comparison of the health‐related quality of life in patients with diabetic foot ulcers, with a diabetes group and a non diabetes group from the general population. Quality of Life Research 2007;16(2):179‐89. - PubMed
Roberts 2001
-
- Roberts GH, Hammad LH, Haggan G, Baker N, Sandeman D, Mani R, et al. Hydrocellular against non‐adherent dressings to treat diabetic foot ulcers. A randomised controlled study. Wound Repair and Regeneration 2001;9(5):402.
Schaper 2004
-
- Schaper NC. Diabetic foot ulcer classification system for research purposes: a progress report on criteria for including patients in research studies. Diabetes Metabolism and Research Review 2004;20(S1):S90‐5. - PubMed
Shea 2007
Singh 2005
-
- Singh N, Armstrong DG, Lipsky BA. Preventing foot ulcers in patients with diabetes. JAMA 2005;293(2):217‐28. - PubMed
Smith 2003
-
- Smith J. A national survey of podiatry practice in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. Unpublished.
Steed 2006
-
- Steed DL, Attinger C, Colaizzi T, Crossland M, Franz M, Harkless L, et al. Guidelines for the treatment of diabetic ulcers. Wound Repair and Regeneration 2006;14(6):680‐92. - PubMed
Tian 2014
-
- Tian X, Yi L‐J, Ma L, Zhang L, Song G‐M, Wang Y. Effects of honey dressing for the treatment of DFUs: a systematic review. International Journal of Nursing Sciences 2014;1:224‐31.
Van Gils 1999
-
- Gils C, Wheeler LA, Mellsrom M, Brinton EA, Mason S, Wheeler CG. Amputation prevention by vascular surgery and podiatry collaboration in high risk diabetic and non‐diabetic patients ‐ the operation desert foot experience. Diabetes Care 1999;22(5):678‐83. - PubMed
Vandeputte 1997
-
- Vandeputte J, Gryson L. Diabetic foot infection controlled by immuno‐modulating hydrogel containing 65% glycerine. Presentation of a clinical trial. 6th European Conference on Advances in Wound Management. Amsterdam, 1997:50‐3.
Veves 2002
-
- Veves A, Sheehan P, Pham HT. A randomized controlled trial of Promogran (a collagen/oxidised regenerated cellulose dressing) vs. standard treatment in the management of diabetic foot ulcers. Archives of Surgery 2002;137:822‐7. - PubMed
Wagner 1981
-
- Wagner FW. The dysvascular foot: a system of diagnosis and treatment. Foot and Ankle 1981;2:64‐122. - PubMed
Ware 2001
-
- Ware JE, Koninski M. SF‐36. Physical and mental health summary scores: a manual for users of version 1.2. Rhode Island: Qualitymetric, 2001.
WHO 2005
-
- Diabetes estimates and projections. http//www.who.int/diabetes/facts/world‐figures/en/index4.html (accessed 23 February 2011).
Wild 2004
-
- Wild S. Global prevalence of diabetes estimates for the year 2000 and projections for 2030. Diabetes Care 2004;27(5):1047‐53. - PubMed
Winter 1963
-
- Winter GD, Scales JT. Effect of air drying and dressings on the surface of a wound. Nature 1963;197:91. - PubMed
Wrobel 2001
-
- Wrobel JS, Mayfield JA, Reiber GE. Geographic variation of lower limb extremity major amputation in individuals with and without diabetes in the Medicare population. Diabetes Care 2001;24(5):860‐4. - PubMed
Publication types
MeSH terms
Grants and funding
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
Medical
Miscellaneous
