Time Trends in Rates of Hodgkin Lymphoma Histologic Subtypes: True Incidence Changes or Evolving Diagnostic Practice?

Abstract

Background: Histologic subtypes of classical Hodgkin lymphoma [cHL; e.g., nodular sclerosis, mixed cellularity, not otherwise specified (NOS)] are epidemiologically and prognostically distinctive. Therefore, unexplained, ongoing incidence rate declines for mixed cellularity and increases for NOS require examination.

Methods: We analyzed detailed histology-specific Hodgkin lymphoma incidence rates in 1992 through 2011 U.S. SEER data (n = 21,372) and reviewed a regional subset of 2007 through 2011 NOS pathology reports for insight into diagnostic practices.

Results: cHL rates were stable until 2007, then decreased for whites [annual percent change (APC) and 95% confidence interval (CI), -3.6% (-5.6% to -1.5%)]. Nodular sclerosis rates declined after 2007 by 5.9% annually, with variation by gender, age, and race/ethnicity. In 1992 through 2011, mixed cellularity rates declined [APC -4.0% (-4.7% to -3.3%)], whereas NOS rates rose [5.3% (4.5%-6.2%)] overall and in most patient groups. The 2007-2011 NOS age-specific rates were more similar to mixed cellularity rates for 1992-1996 than 2007-2011. Trends in combined rates were minimal, supporting increasing misclassification of mixed cellularity, lymphocyte depletion, and specific nodular sclerosis subtypes as NOS. Eighty-eight of 165 reviewed NOS pathology reports addressed classification choice. Twenty (12.1%) justified the classification, 21 (12.7%) described insufficient biopsy material, and coders missed specific subtype information for 27 (16.4%).

Conclusion: Recent nodular sclerosis rate declines largely represent true incidence changes. Long-term rate decreases for mixed cellularity and other less common subtypes, and increases for NOS (comprising ∼30% of cHL cases in 2011), likely reflect changes in diagnostic and/or classification practice.

Impact: Diminishing histologic subtyping undermines future surveillance and epidemiologic study of Hodgkin lymphoma. Guideline-based use of excisional biopsies and more coding quality control are warranted.

Figure 1

Annual age-adjusted incidence rates of Hodgkin lymphoma by histologic subtype and year of diagnosis, 1992–2011, SEER (13 registries)

Figure 2

Annual age-adjusted incidence rates*, and Joinpoint trend lines, of selected Hodgkin lymphoma histologic subtypes by patient and tumor characteristics, 1992–2011, SEER (13 registries)

Figure 2

Annual age-adjusted incidence rates*, and Joinpoint trend lines, of selected Hodgkin lymphoma histologic subtypes by patient and tumor characteristics, 1992–2011, SEER (13 registries)

Figure 3

Annual age-adjusted incidence rates*, and Joinpoint trend lines, of nodular sclerosis Hodgkin lymphoma subtypes by patient and tumor characteristics, 1992–2011, SEER (13 registries)

Figure 3

Annual age-adjusted incidence rates*, and Joinpoint trend lines, of nodular sclerosis Hodgkin lymphoma subtypes by patient and tumor characteristics, 1992–2011, SEER (13 registries)