Juvenile osteochondritis dissecans of the talus: predictors of conservative treatment failure

Abstract

Background: The ideal treatment for juvenile osteochondritis dissecans of the talus (ODT) is still unclear. To determine predictors of failure of conservative treatment, children admitted for ODT were retrospectively analyzed.

Methods: Patient files were analyzed to search for children treated for an ODT between 2000 and 2011. X-rays and MRI at baseline were evaluated for grading of lesions and the patient history was obtained. Final follow-up evaluation was performed via questionnaire and complementary telephone interview. Outcome was measured using the AOFAS and the Olerud/Molander scores. Conservative treatment consisted of out of sports and modification of activity under full weight-bearing. In case of persisting pain, full load removal on crutches was initiated. For further analysis, two groups were formed: (1) successful conservative treatment; (2) converted to surgical therapy. A logistic regression was used to determine potential predictors of conservative treatment failure.

Results: Seventy-seven lesions in 67 children with a mean age of 11.4 years (range 4-15 years) at the time of diagnosis were identified. Every patient received conservative treatment as a first-line treatment after diagnosis of ODT except for one single patient with a grade IV lesion at time of diagnosis who received operative treatment directly after diagnosis. Sixty-one percent of the lesions failed conservative treatment. A higher age as well as a grade III lesion at time of diagnosis was predictive for failure of the conservative treatment (p = 0.03 and p = 0.02, respectively). Regarding the functional outcome, a higher grade lesion in general was predictive for an inferior outcome as measured by clinical score.

Conclusion: Grade III ODT especially in older children leads significantly more often to treatment failure when treated non-surgically. No other predictors for treatment failure could be identified.

Level of evidence: Level III (retrospective comparative study).

Keywords: Juvenile osteochondritis dissecans; Talus; Treatment.