Development and validation of the Nancy histological index for UC

Abstract

Objective: We developed a validated index for assessing histological disease activity in UC and established its responsiveness.

Methods: Two hundred biopsies were scored. The outcome was the Global Visual Evaluation (GVE). Eight histological features were tested. The Nancy index was developed by multiple linear regression and bootstrap process to create an index that best matched the GVE. Goodness of fit was assessed by the adjusted R squared (adjusted R²). The second step was the validation of the index: 100 biopsies were scored for the Nancy index by three pathologists from different centres. Inter-reader reliability was evaluated for each reader. The relationship between the change of the Nancy index and the Geboes index was assessed to assess the responsiveness.

Results: After backward selection with bootstrap validation, 3/8 items were selected: ulceration (adjusted R²=0.55), acute inflammatory infiltrate (adjusted R²=0.88) and chronic inflammatory infiltrate (adjusted R²=0.79). The Nancy index is defined by a 5-level classification ranging from grade 0 (absence of significant histological disease activity) to grade 4 (severely active disease). The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for the intrareader reliability was 0.88 (95% CI 0.82 to 0.92) and the index had good inter-reader reliability (ICC=0.86 (0.81 to 0.99)). The correlation between the Nancy index and the Geboes score or the GVE was very good. The index had a good responsiveness with a high correlation between changes in the Geboes score and changes in the Nancy index (0.910 (0.813 to 0.955)).

Conclusions: A three descriptor histological index has been validated for use in clinical practice and clinical trials.

Keywords: MUCOSAL PATHOLOGY; ULCERATIVE COLITIS.