Sphincterplasty for Velopharyngeal Insufficiency in the Child Without a Cleft-Palate: Etiologies and Speech Outcomes

Abstract

The aim of this study is to report on speech outcomes following surgery for velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) on a broad spectrum of patients without a cleft palate. Inclusion criteria included patients without a cleft palate operated on by a single surgeon (JKW) over a 10-year period and postoperative speech evaluation within 1 year. All patients underwent a sphincter pharyngoplasty. The main outcome measures were perceptual speech assessment using a 6-point scale (1 = none or normal, 6 = severe); velopharyngeal function (VPF) (1 = adequate, 2 = marginal, 3 = dequate); and quantitative nasalance score. Forty children (mean age 7.5 y) were included. Eight unique conditions were identified; the most common was 22q deletion syndromes (27.5%). All patients had a deep nasopharynx, mean nasopharyngeal depth >0.67. Two novel cases are presented in each child with mosaic Trisomy 14 and ring chromosome 18 abnormality. Of all patients, 87.5% improved their postoperative hypernasality score. Preoperatively, all patients had either marginal or inadequate VPF (2 or 3). Postoperatively, 90% of patients (n = 36) achieved adequate velar function, the remainder did not improve at the first postoperative evaluation. Intelligibility and audible nasal emissions improved in between 57% and 65% of patients. Articulation proficiency was the only perceptual rating not to improve initially, but then did so on the most recent postoperative speech evaluation. This study demonstrates successful speech outcomes in a diverse group of patients. It also increases awareness of noncleft VPI amenable to surgical correction.