Union rate after operative treatment of humeral shaft nonunion--A systematic review

Abstract

Introduction: Humeral shaft nonunions can lead to morbidity from subsequent operations, complications and impaired function. Currently there is no evidenced-based consensus for treatment of humeral shaft nonunions.

Aim: We aimed to summarize and analyze union rates and complications after operative treatment for humeral shaft nonunion.

Methods: Studies investigating operative treatment strategies for humeral shaft nonunion were identified by searching: EMBASE, MEDLINE, Ovid SP, Web of Science, Cochrane Central, PubMed and Google Scolar up to October 24, 2014. Studies were eligible if: (1) outcome of operative treatment for humeral shaft nonunion was reported; (2) at least ten adult patients with humeral shaft nonunion included; (3) full text article available; (4) written in English, German or Dutch; and (5) nonunion was defined as no bone-bridging between the fracture ends after 6 months.

Results: Thirty-six studies were included. A union rate of 98% was found in patients (n=672) who underwent plate fixation with autologous bone grafting (ABG), 95% in plate fixation without ABG (n=19), 88% in intramedullary nailing with ABG (n=164), 66% in intramedullary nailing without ABG (n=78), 92% in bone strut fixation (n=91) and 98% in external fixation (n=152). A total complication rate of 12% was found in patients treated with plate fixation combined with ABG, 15% in intramedullary nail with ABG and 8% intramedullary nailing without ABG, 20% in bone strut fixation and 22% in external fixation.

Conclusion: Plate fixation with ABG was recommended for humeral shaft nonunion, since the union rate is highest and the complication rate is relatively low.

Level of evidence: Level IV.

Keywords: Humeral shaft; Nonunion; Treatment; Union rate.