Non-pharmacological interventions for depression in adults and children with traumatic brain injury
- PMID: 26663136
- PMCID: PMC8761477
- DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD009871.pub2
Non-pharmacological interventions for depression in adults and children with traumatic brain injury
Abstract
Background: Following traumatic brain injury (TBI) there is an increased prevalence of depression compared to the general population. It is unknown whether non-pharmacological interventions for depression are effective for people with TBI.
Objectives: To investigate the effectiveness of non-pharmacological interventions for depression in adults and children with TBI at reducing the diagnosis and severity of symptoms of depression.
Search methods: We ran the most recent search on 11 February 2015. We searched the Cochrane Injuries Group Specialised Register, The Cochrane Library, MEDLINE (OvidSP), Embase (OvidSP), three other databases and clinical trials registers. Relevant conference proceedings and journals were handsearched, as were the reference lists of identified studies.
Selection criteria: Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of non-pharmacological interventions for depression in adults and children who had a TBI.
Data collection and analysis: Two authors independently selected trials from the search results, then assessed risk of bias and extracted data from the included trials. The authors contacted trial investigators to obtain missing information. We rated the overall quality of the evidence of the primary outcomes using the GRADE approach.
Main results: Six studies met the inclusion criteria, with a total of 334 adult participants. We identified no studies that included children as participants. All studies were affected by high risk of bias due to a lack of blinding of participants and personnel; five studies were affected by high risk of bias for lack of blinding of outcome assessors. There was high or unclear risk of biases affecting some studies across all the Cochrane risk of bias measures.Three studies compared a psychological intervention (either cognitive behaviour therapy or mindfulness-based cognitive therapy) with a control intervention. Data regarding depression symptom outcome measures were combined in a meta-analysis, but did not find an effect in favour of treatment (SMD -0.14; 95% CI -0.47 to 0.19; Z = 0.83; P = 0.41). The other comparisons comprised of single studies of depression symptoms and compared; cognitive behaviour therapy versus supportive psychotherapy (SMD -0.09; 95% CI -0.65 to 0.48; Z = 0.30; P = 0.77); repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation plus tricyclic antidepressant (rTMS + TCA) versus tricyclic antidepressant alone (SMD -0.84; 95% CI -1.36 to -0.32; Z = 3;19, P = 0.001); and a supervised exercise program versus exercise as usual (SMD -0.43; 95% CI -0.88 to 0.03; Z = 1.84; P = 0.07). There was very-low quality evidence, small effect sizes and wide variability of results, suggesting that no comparisons showed a reliable effect for any intervention.Only one study mentioned minor, transient adverse events from repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation.
Authors' conclusions: The review did not find compelling evidence in favour of any intervention. Future studies should focus on participants with a diagnosed TBI and include only participants who have a diagnosis of depression, or who record scores above a clinical cutoff on a depression measure. There is a need for additional RCTs that include a comparison between an intervention and a control that replicates the effect of the attention given to participants during an active treatment.
Conflict of interest statement
PG: None known.
RT: None known.
IC: None known.
Figures
Update of
References
References to studies included in this review
Ashman 2014 {published data only}
-
- Ashman T, Cantor J, Tsaousides T, Spielman L, Gordon W. Comparison of cognitive behavioral therapy and supportive psychotherapy for the treatment of depression following traumatic brain injury: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2014;29:467‐78. [clinicaltrials.gov (ID: NCT00211835)] - PubMed
-
- Ashman T, Tsaousides T. Cognitive behavioral therapy for depression following traumatic brain injury: findings of a randomized controlled trial. Brain Impairment. Bergen, 2012; Vol. 13:124‐31. [DOI: 10.1017/BrImp.2012.10] - DOI
Bedard 2013 {published data only}
-
- Bédard M, Felteau M, Marshall S, Cullen N, Gibbons C, Dubois S, et al. Mindfulness‐based cognitive therapy reduces symptoms of depression in people with a traumatic brain injury: results from a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2013;29(4):E13‐22. [Trialscentral.org (ID: NCT00745940)] - PubMed
Fann 2015 {published data only}
He 2004 {published data only}
-
- He CS, Yu Q, Yang DJ, Yang M. Interventional effects of low‐frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on patients with depression after traumatic brain injury. Chinese Journal of Clinical Rehabilitation 2004;8:6044‐5.
Hoffman 2010 {published data only}
-
- Hoffman JM, Bell KR, Powell JM, Behr J, Dunn EC, Dikmen S, et al. Randomized controlled trial of exercise to improve mood after traumatic brain injury. Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 2010;2:911‐9. - PubMed
Simpson 2011 {published data only}
-
- Simpson GK, Tate RL, Whiting DL, Cotter RE. Suicide prevention after traumatic brain injury: a randomized controlled trial of a program for the psychological treatment of hopelessness. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2011;26:290‐300. - PubMed
References to studies excluded from this review
Anson 2006 {published data only}
-
- Anson K, Ponsford J. Evaluation of a coping skills group following traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury 2006;20:167‐78. - PubMed
Bateman 2001 {published data only}
-
- Bateman A, Culpan FJ, Pickering AD, Powell JH, Scott OM, Greenwood RJ. The effect of aerobic training on rehabilitation outcomes after recent severe brain injury: A randomized controlled evaluation. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 2001;82:174‐82. - PubMed
Bell 2008 {published data only}
-
- Bell KR, Hoffman JM, Temkin NR, Powell JM, Fraser RT, Esselman PC, et al. The effect of telephone counselling on reducing post‐traumatic symptoms after mild traumatic brain injury: a randomised trial. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 2008;79:1275‐81. - PubMed
Bombardier 2009 {published data only}
-
- Bombardier CH, Bell KR, Temkin NR, Fann JR, Hoffman J, Dikmen S. The efficacy of a scheduled telephone intervention for ameliorating depressive symptoms during the first year after traumatic brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2009;24:230‐8. - PubMed
Bradbury 2008 {published data only}
-
- Bradbury CL, Christensen BK, Lau MA, Ruttan LA, Arundine AL, Green RE. The efficacy of cognitive behavior therapy in the treatment of emotional distress after acquired brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 2008; Vol. 89, issue 12:S61‐8. - PubMed
Carey 2008 {published data only}
Cullen 2007 {published data only}
-
- Cullen N, Chundamala J, Bayley M, Jutai J. The efficacy of acquired brain injury rehabilitation (Structured abstract). Brain Injury 2007;21:113‐32. - PubMed
Driver 2009 {published data only}
Fleming 2009 {published data only}
Geurtsen 2008 {published data only}
-
- Geurtsen GJ, Martina JD, Heugten CM, Geurts AC. A prospective study to evaluate a new residential community reintegration programme for severe chronic brain injury: The Brain Integration Programme. Brain Injury 2008;22(7‐8):545‐54. - PubMed
Ghaffar 2006 {published data only}
-
- Ghaffar O, McCullagh S, Ouchterlony D, Feinstein A. Randomized treatment trial in mild traumatic brain injury. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 2006;61:153‐60. - PubMed
Huckans 2010 {published data only}
-
- Huckans M, Pavawalla S, Demadura T, Kolessar M, Seelye A, Roost N, et al. A pilot study examining effects of group‐based cognitive strategy training treatment on self‐reported cognitive problems, psychiatric symptoms, functioning, and compensatory strategy use in OIF/OEF combat veterans with persistent mild cognitive disorder and history of traumatic brain injury. Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 2010;47:43‐60. - PMC - PubMed
Leonard 2004 {published data only}
-
- Leonard KN. Cognitive‐behavioral intervention in persistent postconcussion syndrome: A controlled treatment outcome study. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering. ProQuest Information & Learning. US, 2004:6332.
McDonald 2008 {published data only}
-
- McDonald S, Tate R, Togher L, Bornhofen C, Long E, Gertler P, et al. Social skills treatment for people with severe, chronic acquired brain injuries: a multicenter trial. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. School of Psychology, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia. s.mcdonald@unsw.edu.au, 2008; Vol. 89, issue 9:1648‐59. - PubMed
Powell 2002 {published data only}
Ruff 1990 {published data only}
-
- Ruff RM, Niemann H. Cognitive rehabilitation versus day treatment in head‐injured adults: is there an impact on emotional and psychosocial adjustment?. Brain Injury. UCSD Head Injury Center, Learning Services Institute, San Diego, California 92103., 1990; Vol. 4, issue 4:339‐47. - PubMed
Smith 1994 {published data only}
-
- Smith RB, Tiberi A, Marshall J. The use of cranial electrotherapy stimulation in the treatment of closed‐head‐injured patients. Brain Injury 1994;8(4):357‐61. - PubMed
Stocksmeier 1992 {published data only}
-
- Stocksmeier U, Eberlein M. Depressive emotional deterioration in case of brain function disorders. TW Neurologie Psychiatrie 1992;6:74‐6.
Stoll 1999 {published data only}
-
- Stoll JL. Effects of therapeutic massage on the psychosocial adjustment of persons with brain injury. University of Wisconsin ‐ Madison. University of Wisconsin ‐ Madison, 1999.
Struchen 2011 {published data only}
-
- Struchen MA, Davis LC, Bogaards JA, Hudler‐Hull T, Clark AN, Mazzei DM, et al. Making connections after brain injury: Development and evaluation of a social peer‐mentoring program for persons with traumatic brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2011;26:4‐19. - PubMed
Sun 2008 {published data only}
-
- Sun M, Zhan XP, Jin CY, Shan JZ, Xu S, Wang YL. Clinical observation on treatment of post‐craniocerebral traumatic mental disorder by integrative medicine. Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine 2008;14:137‐41. - PubMed
Teasdale 1995 {published data only}
-
- Teasdale TW, Caetano C. Psychopathological symptomatology in brain‐injured patients before and after a rehabilitation program. Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development. Lawrence Erlbaum. US, 1995; Vol. 2, issue 3‐4:116‐23. - PubMed
Tiersky 2005 {published data only}
-
- Tiersky LA, Anselmi V, Johnston MV, Kurtyka J, Roosen E, Schwartz T, et al. A trial of neuropsychologic rehabilitation in mild‐spectrum traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 2005; Vol. 86, issue 8:1565‐74. - PubMed
Wade 2006 {published data only}
-
- Wade SL, Michaud L, Brown TM. Putting the pieces together: Preliminary efficacy of a family problem‐solving intervention for children with traumatic brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2006;21(1):57‐67. - PubMed
Wade 2008 {published data only}
References to studies awaiting assessment
NCT01039857 {published data only}
-
- Hofer H, Grosse Holftforth M, Stalder‐Luthy F, Frischknecht E, Muri R, Znoj H. Does an integrative neuro‐psychotherapy program foster the adjustment in depressed patients with an acquired brain injury? Joint Meeting of the FESN/GNP; 2013 Sept 12‐14; Berlin Germany. Behavioural Neurology. 2013:329‐30. [NCT01039857]
References to ongoing studies
Clark 2014 {published data only}
-
- Clark A. A randomized controlled trial of a modified group cognitive behavioural intervention for depressed mood following traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury 2014 Conference: 10th World Congress on Brain Injury of the International Brain Injury Association; 2014 March 19 ‐ 22; San Francisco, CA. 2014.
NCT00531258 {published data only}
-
- NCT00531258. Transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of the sequelae of closed brain injury. www.clinicaltrials.gov 19 Sept 2012.
NCT01691378 {published data only}
-
- Brenner L, Simpson G, Forster J, Signoracci G, Matarazzo B, Clemans T. Window to hope: Preliminary results from a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of a psychological treatment for hopelessness among US veterans with traumatic brain injury (TBI). Brain Injury 2014;28(5‐6):737. [NCT01691378]
NCT02367521 {published data only}
-
- NCT02367521. Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS) for the Treatment of Depression & Other Neuropsychiatric Symptoms After Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) (rTMS TBI). www.clinicaltrials.gov 14 December 2015.
Additional references
Alderfer 2005
-
- Alderfer BS, Arciniegas DB, Silver JM. Treatment of depression following traumatic brain injury. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2005;20:544‐62. - PubMed
APA 2000
-
- American Psychiatric Association (APA). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th Edition. Washington D.C.: APA, 2000.
Barker‐Collo 2013
-
- Barker‐Collo S, Starkey N, Theadom A. Treatment for depression following mild traumatic brain injury in adults: A meta‐analysis. Brain Injury 2013;27:1124‐33. - PubMed
Bay 2009
-
- Bay E. Current treatment options for depression after mild traumatic brain injury. Current Treatment Options in Neurology 2009;11:377‐82. - PubMed
Bombadier 2010
Caldwell 2010
Churchill 2010a
Churchill 2010b
Churchill 2010c
Churchill 2010e
Churchill 2013
Ciurli 2011
-
- Ciurli P, Formisano R, Bivona U, Cantagallo A, Angelelli P. Neuropsychiatric disorders in persons with severe traumatic brain injury: prevalence, phenomenology, and relationship with demographic, clinical, and functional features. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 2011;26:116‐26. - PubMed
Cooney 2013
Cox 2012
-
- Cox GR, Callahan P, Churchill R, Hunot V, Merry SN, Parker AG, et al. Psychological therapies versus antidepressant medication, alone and in combination for depression in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2012, Issue 11. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD008324.pub2] - DOI - PubMed
Davies 2010
Deb 1999
-
- Deb S, Lyons I, Koutzoukis C, Ali I, McCarthy G. Rate of psychiatric illness 1 year after traumatic brain injury. American Journal of Psychiatry 1999;156:374‐8. - PubMed
Dikmen 2004
-
- Dikmen SS, Bombardier CH, Machamer JE, Fann JR, Temkin NR. Natural history of depression in traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 2004;85:1457‐64. - PubMed
Fann 2009
Fitzgerald 2011
-
- Fitzgerald PB, Hoy KE, Maller JJ, Herring S, Segrave R, McQueen S, et al. Transcranial magnetic stimulation for depression after a traumatic brain injury: a case study. Journal of ECT 2011;27:38‐40. - PubMed
Green 2001
-
- Green A, Felmingham K, Baguley IJ, Slewa‐Younan S, Simpson S. The clinical utility of the Beck Depression Inventory after traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury 2001;15:1021‐8. - PubMed
Guillamondegui 2011
-
- Guillamondegui OD, Montgomery SA, Phibbs FT, McPheeters ML, Alexander PT, Jerome RN, et al. Traumatic Brain Injury and Depression. Comparative Effectiveness Review No. 25. (Prepared by the Vanderbilt Evidence‐based Practice Center under Contract No. 290‐2007‐10065‐I.) AHRQ Publication No. 11‐EHC017‐EF. Available at: www.effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/reports/final.cfm.. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, April 2011. - PubMed
Hamilton 1960
Henken 2007
Higgins 2011
-
- Higgins JPT, Green S. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from www.cochrane‐handbook.org.
Hunot 2010
Hunot 2010a
Hunot 2013
Jorm 2008
Kay 1993
-
- Kay T, Harrington DE, Adams R, Anderson T, Berrol S, Cicerone K, et al. Definition of mild traumatic brain injury. Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 1993;8:86‐7.
Khan‐Bourne 2003
-
- Khan‐Bourne N, Browne RG. Cognitive behaviour therapy for the treatment of depression in individuals with brain injury. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 2003;13:89‐107. - PubMed
Larun 2006
Leiknes 2011
-
- Leiknes KA, Berg RC, Smedslund G, Jarosch‐von Schweder SL, Øverland S, Hammerstrøm KT, et al. Electroconvulsive therapy for depression. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2011, Issue 5. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD009105] - DOI
Maas 2008
-
- Maas AI, Stocchetti N, Bullock R. Moderate and severe traumatic brain injury in adults. Lancet Neurology 2008;7(8):728‐41. - PubMed
Maratos 2008
Moore 2010
NICE 2009
-
- National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). Depression: The treatment and management of depression in adults. CG90. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. London, 2009.
Ownsworth 2008
-
- Ownsworth T, Trudi L, Turner B, Hawkes A, Shum D. Assessing emotional status following acquired brain injury: The clinical potential of the depression, anxiety and stress scales. Brain Injury 2008;22:858‐69. - PubMed
Poggi 2005
-
- Poggi G, Liscio M, Adduci A, Galbiati S, Massimino M, Sommovigo M, et al. Psychological and adjustment problems due to acquired brain lesions in childhood: a comparison between post‐traumatic patients and brain tumour survivors. Brain Injury 2005;19(10):777‐85. - PubMed
Rapoport 2012
-
- Rapoport 2012. Depression following traumatic brain injury: Epidemiology, risk factors and management. CNS Drugs 2012;26:111‐21. - PubMed
Rodriguez‐Martin 2001
Rosenthal 1998
-
- Rosenthal M, Christensen BK, Ross TP. Depression following traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 1998;79:90‐103. - PubMed
Shinohara 2013
Silver 2009
-
- Silver JM, McAllister TW, Arciniegas DB. Depression and cognitive complaints following mild traumatic brain injury. American Journal of Psychiatry 2009;166:653‐61. - PubMed
Simpson 2002
-
- Simpson G, Tate R. Suicidality after traumatic brain injury: demographic, injury and clinical correlates. Psychological Medicine 2002;32:687‐97. - PubMed
Slade 2009
-
- Slade T, Johnston A, Oakley‐Browne MA, Andrews G, Whiteford H. 2007 National Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing: methods and key findings. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2009;43:594‐605. - PubMed
Sliwinski 1998
-
- Sliwinski M, Gordon W, Bogdany J. The Beck Depression Inventory: Is it a suitable measure of depression for individuals with traumatic brain injury?. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 1998;13:40‐6. - PubMed
Smith 2010
Snell 2009
-
- Snell DL, Surgenor LJ, Hay‐Smith EJC, Siegert RJ. A systematic review of psychological treatments for mild traumatic brain injury: An update on the evidence. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology 2009;31:20‐38. - PubMed
Tuunainen 2004
Vattakatuchery 2013
-
- Vattakatuchery J, Lathif N, Joy J, Cavanna A, Rickards HE. Pharmacological interventions for depression in people with traumatic brain injury. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2013, Issue 3. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD010419] - DOI
Waldron 2013
Whitnall 2006
WHO 1992
-
- World Health Organization (WHO). The ICD‐10 Classification of Mental and Behavioral Disorders: Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Manual. Geneva: WHO, 1992.
Publication types
MeSH terms
Substances
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
Medical
Miscellaneous
