Trends in molecular epidemiology of drug-resistant tuberculosis in Republic of Karelia, Russian Federation

Abstract

Background: Russian Republic of Karelia is located at the Russian-Finnish border. It contains most of the historical Karelia land inhabited with autochthonous Karels and more recently migrated Russians. Although tuberculosis (TB) incidence in Karelia is decreasing, it remains high (45.8/100 000 in 2014) with the rate of multi-drug resistance (MDR) among newly diagnosed TB patients reaching 46.5 %. The study aimed to genetically characterize Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates obtained at different time points from TB patients from Karelia to gain insight into the phylogeographic specificity of the circulating genotypes and to assess trends in evolution of drug resistant subpopulations.

Methods: The sample included 150 M. tuberculosis isolates: 78 isolated in 2013-2014 ("new" collection) and 72 isolated in 2006 ("old" collection). Drug susceptibility testing was done by the method of absolute concentrations. Spoligotyping was used to test genotype-specific markers of a Latin-American-Mediterranean (LAM) family and its sublineages as well as a Beijing B0/W148-cluster.

Results: The largest spoligotypes were SIT1 (Beijing family, n = 42) and SIT40 (T family, n = 5). Beijing family was the largest (n = 43) followed by T (n = 11), Ural (n = 10) and LAM (n = 8). Successful Russian clone, Beijing В0/W148, was identified in 15 (34.9 %) of 43 Beijing isolates; all В0/W148 isolates were drug-resistant. Seven of 8 LAM isolates belonged to the RD115/LAM-RUS branch, 1 - to the LAM RD174/RD-Rio sublineage. MDR was found in Beijing (32/43), Ural (3/10), and LAM (3/8). In contrast, all T isolates were pansusceptible. Comparison of drug resistant subgroups of the new and old collections showed an increasing prevalence of the B0/W148 clonal cluster, from 18.0 % (mainly polyresistant) in 2006 to 32.6 % in 2014 (mainly MDR and pre-XDR). The West-east increasing gradient is observed for the Ural genotype that may be defined a 'Russian' strain. In contrast, the spoligotype SIT40 of the T family appears to be a historical Karelian strain.

Conclusions: Circulation of the MDR M. tuberculosis isolates of the Beijing genotype and its B0/W148 cluster continues to critically influence the current situation with the MDR-TB control in northwestern Russia including the Republic of Karelia. Revealed phylogeographic patterns of some genotypes reflect a complex demographic history of Karelia within the course of the 20(th) century.

Fig. 1

Distribution of M. tuberculosis genotypes (collection 2013–2014) in different regions of Karelia Circle size is roughly proportional to the sample size. Ptz = Petrozavodsk. Free map: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Karelia_today.png

Fig. 2

Distribution of M. tuberculosis genotypes in Karelia (collection 2013–2014) in its neighboring regions in Russia, and in Finland. Circle size is not proportional to the sample size. The same color coding is used as in Fig 1, but Beijing genotype is shown by a single yellow color, without separate shading of the Beijing B0/W148 variant. Free map: http://s8366.chomikuj.pl/ChomikImage.aspx?e=6c-SLnsUnfRfdfr7pJzD_Ks6q2jz1mmsSXERXBmYqw0C3H5OBm9Si_yGn7ckP54SV8PouVOQiyMi4FM5truhxxxGI_tRJhzFlrimtfVsbns&pv=2