Distinction between obstructive and nonobstructive pyelocaliectasis with duplex Doppler sonography

Abstract

Because animal studies have shown that renal obstruction increases renal vascular resistance, we theorized that obstruction would change the Doppler waveform. We studied the value of the resistive index (RI) calculated from the duplex Doppler waveform to distinguish between obstructive and nonobstructive pyelocaliectasis in 229 kidneys in 133 patients. The RI is the peak systolic frequency shift minus the minimum diastolic frequency shift, then divided by the peak systolic frequency shift. Duplex Doppler sonography was performed prospectively in 70 kidneys with pyelocaliectasis before the presence or absence of obstruction was established. In 54 of 70 kidneys, the presence or absence of obstruction was proved by interventional methods (percutaneous nephrostomy, antegrade or retrograde pyelography, loopography), and in the rest it was proved by body CT, excretory urography, or surgery. Thirty-eight kidneys were found to be obstructed, and 32 had nonobstructive dilatation. In addition, 159 kidneys without pyelocaliectasis were studied to identify possible limitations of Doppler sonography in the diagnosis of obstruction. Clinical history and laboratory data were used to determine that 109 of these kidneys were in normal subjects and 50 were in patients with nondilated renal disease. There was a significant difference between the mean RI of the obstructed (0.77 +/- 0.05) and the nonobstructed dilated (0.63 +/- 0.06) kidneys (p less than .01). Analysis of the receiver-operating-characteristic curve showed an RI of 0.70 to be a good discriminatory level for obstruction, resulting in a sensitivity of 92%, a specificity of 88%, and an accuracy of 90%. All 109 normal kidneys had an RI less than 0.70. Over half (27/50) of the kidneys in patients with nondilated renal disease had an elevated RI (greater than or equal to 0.70). Ninety-six patients had Doppler examinations on both kidneys, and in only six patients did the RI values of each kidney differ by more than 0.10; all six were proved to have unilateral obstruction. Use of duplex Doppler sonography should improve the specificity, and thus the accuracy, of sonography in the noninvasive diagnosis of obstruction and should be used when a dilated collecting system is identified.