The introductory placebo washout: a retrospective evaluation

Abstract

We examined the effects of the "introductory placebo washout" technique by reanalyzing the results of a recent trial of an experimental antidepressant. At the beginning, all patients were placed on placebo in a single-blind design. Patients who were rated as placebo responders with the physician-administered Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HRSD) were excluded from the trial. In spite of this technique, an alternative measure of depression indicated that many patients with a positive response to placebo had been entered in the trial. In the reanalysis, elimination of these "hidden placebo responders" did not lower the final placebo response rate and actually diminished the differences observed at the end of the study between the active treatment and placebo groups. These data suggest that the introductory placebo washout may have unpredictable, possibly confounding effects on patient samples in trials of antidepressant agents.