Comparison of oxazepam, flurazepam and chloral hydrate as hypnotic sedatives in geriatric patients

Abstract

In a four-week study, a comparison was made of oxazepam, flurazepam and chloral hydrate as hypnotic sedatives in 17 geriatric patients. Each drug was given alone for six nights, with a two-night placebo interval following each phase. Each patient completed an additional placebo phase (up to six nights) before each drug phase. The number of awakenings per night and the sleep latency (time required to fall asleep) were determined from the patients' reports and from the reports of a nurse-observer. Only for oxazepam was the number of patient-reported awakenings per night significantly less than for placebo, although with both oxazepam and flurazepam the awakenings were fewer than with chloral hydrate. According to the patient-reports, sleep latency was significantly lower with flurazepam than with placebo; for oxazepam and chloral hydrate the latencies were not significantly different from those for flurazepam or placebo. Only for oxazepam were the patients' ratings of sleep quality significantly greater than for placebo. The objective assessment of sleep by the nurse-observer usually confirmed the patients' assessments. Morning drowsiness was the most common side effect, reported equally for placebo and for the active drugs. Drowsiness during the day was reported less frequently for oxazepam than for flurazepam, chloral hydrate or placebo. It is concluded that oxazepam is safe and efficacious for the short-term management of insomnia in the elderly.