Tracheotomy-Related Deaths

Abstract

Background: Tracheotomies are frequently performed on ventilated patients in intensive care and sometimes lead to fatal complications. In this article, we discuss the causes and frequency of death associated with open surgical tracheotomy (OST) and percutaneous dilatational tracheotomy (PDT) on the basis of a review of the pertinent literature.

Methods: We systematically searched the PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library databases and the Karlsruhe Virtual Catalog for publications (1990-2015) on tracheotomy-related deaths in adults, using the search terms "tracheotomy" and "tracheostomy." 39 relevant dissertations were included in the analysis as well.

Results: 109 publications were included. Of the 25 056 tracheotomies described, there were 16 827 PDTs and 7934 OSTs; for 295 tracheotomies, the technique used was not stated. 352 deaths were reported, including 113 in patients treated with PDT, 49 in those treated with OST, and 190 deaths related to a tracheotomy without specification of the method used. The frequency of death among patients with OST and those treated with PDT was similar: 0.62% for OST (95% confidence interval [0.47; 0.82]) and 0.67% for PDT ([0.56; 0.81]). The most common causes of death and their frequencies, as a percentage of all tracheotomies, were hemorrhage (OST: 0.26% [0.17; 0.40], PDT: 0.26% [0.19; 0.35]), loss of airway (OST: 0.21% [0.13; 0.34], PDT: 0.20% [0.14; 0.28]), and false passage (OST: 0.11% [0.06; 0.22], PDT: 0.20% [KI 0.15; 0.29]).

Conclusion: Bias in the data cannot be excluded, as these were not epidemiologic data and the documentation was found to be incomplete. The likelihood of a fatal complication seems to be the same with both tracheotomy techniques as far as can be determined from the available evidence. Tracheotomy-related deaths can be avoided in several ways: by thorough training under the leadership of experienced physicians, by the use of the World Health Organization's Surgical Safety Checklist regardless of where the tracheotomy is performed, and by the continuous vigilance of nursing staff.

eFigure 1

Flowchart of publication selection OST, open surgical tracheostomy; PDT, percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy *¹ 4 duplicate publications with 11 deaths *² 8 publications with 10 deaths: PDT-related death not clear 2 publications with 3 deaths: OST-related death not clear 4 dissertations with 7 deaths: Tracheotomy-related death not clear 1 publication with 9 deaths: Not differentiated between brain damage and tracheotomy-related death

eFigure 2

Included publications with tracheotomy-related deaths, origin and number