The treatment of emotional disorders in general practice: psychological methods versus medication

Abstract

This paper describes three recent trials in which psychological methods were evaluated in the treatment of emotional disorders in general practice. In the first trial, brief counselling by the general practitioner was found to be as effective as anxiolytic medication, was welcomed by patients and did not increase demands on doctors' time. In the second trial (still in progress), in which treatment is aimed at emotional disorders of poor prognosis, problem solving treatment by a psychiatrist is being compared with control treatment by the G.P. The third trial evaluated an anxiety management programme provided by clinical psychologists in health centres; substantial reductions in anxiety occurred rapidly and were maintained at follow-up.