Evaluation of six enzyme immunoassays for antibody against human immunodeficiency virus

Abstract

Six commercial enzyme immunoassays (EIA) were evaluated in 6488 serum samples, with immunoblot analysis as the confirmatory test for antibodies against human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). The Abbott and Wellcome tests identified all 163 immunoblot-positive samples correctly, whereas the other tests did not detect 1-3 samples. In AIDS patients (predominantly with antibodies to gp41env) Organon's EIA was less sensitive (p less than 0.05) and Wellcome's more sensitive (p less than 0.05) than the immunoblot assay. In symptom-free anti-HIV-positive subjects (antibodies to almost all viral antigens and high titres of anti-p24gag) all the EIA were significantly (p less than 0.05) less sensitive than the immunoblot assay. The frequencies of false-positive reactions in a "tricky" panel of samples from patients with autoimmune and acute viral diseases and in a blood-donor panel were Abbott 9.5%, 0.42%: Organon 1.7%, 0%; Litton 1.0%, 0.4%; Behring 2.7%, 0.06%; Wellcome 0%, 0%; and Pasteur 0%, 0.02%. The results of a seventh EIA (Dupont) were excluded from the study at the company's request. All six EIA evaluated are suitable tests for anti-HIV screening in samples from patients and blood donors.