Does open lung biopsy affect treatment in patients with diffuse pulmonary infiltrates?

Abstract

The decision to perform open lung biopsy in the evaluation of a diffuse pulmonary infiltrate is based on the probability that this examination will yield specific information that may lead to a change in treatment. The role of this procedure remains controversial and many clinicians are reluctant to allow this invasive procedure without assurances that results will lead to a change in therapy for a significant number. To evaluate the impact of open lung biopsy on diagnosis and treatment of diffuse pulmonary infiltrates, we conducted a retrospective review of 61 patients undergoing this procedure at three university-affiliated hospitals during a recent 7-year period. There were 37 men and 24 women; average age was 57 years. Biopsy yielded a specific diagnosis in 21 (34%) patients and a change in therapy in 33 (54%) patients. A complication developed in 11 (18%) patients, directly related to the biopsy procedure in six (10%). Eight patients died. The immune status in 22 (36%) patients was compromised. A specific diagnosis was obtained in 13 (59%) immunocompromised patients and a change in therapy occurred in 17 (77%) of these patients after biopsy. A specific diagnosis was obtained in only eight (21%) of the 39 noncompromised patients and therapy was changed in 16 (41%) patients in this group (p less than 0.02 compromised versus noncompromised). Morbidity and mortality were not significantly different between the two groups. A nonspecific diagnosis led to a change in therapy as frequently as a specific diagnosis in both compromised and noncompromised groups. Open lung biopsy in the patient with a diffuse pulmonary infiltrate is an accurate diagnostic tool and frequently leads to a change in patient treatment. The procedure can be performed with acceptable morbidity and mortality in immunocompromised and noncompromised patients.