Assay variation in the detection of antinuclear antibodies in the sera of patients with established SLE

Abstract

Objective: The expression of antinuclear antibodies (ANA) is considered almost constant in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), although recent experience has suggested that many subjects with SLE considered for clinical trials are ANA negative at screening. The objective of this study is to determine whether assay variation can influence ANA detection in patients with established SLE.

Methods: Sera from 103 patients with established SLE were tested using three different immunofluorescence assays (IFA) for ANA determination. ANA determinations were also performed by an ELISA and bead-based multiplex assay.

Results: With IFA kits, the frequency of ANA negativity varied from 5 to 23 of 103 samples (4.9%-22.3%). The ELISA and multiplex assays showed that 12 (11.7%) and 14 (13.6%) samples were negative, respectively. Samples positive in all assays differed from those with discordant assay results in the frequency of historical anti-double-stranded DNA positivity and low complement levels at the time of blood sampling.

Discussion: These findings indicate that ANA negativity occurs in patients with established SLE although the frequency varies depending on the assay kit. Given the range of negativity with well-validated assays, these findings raise questions about whether ANA positivity should be employed to determine eligibility for clinical trials.

Keywords: autoantibodies; autoimmune diseases; systemic lupus erythematosus.