A realist approach to eliciting the initial programme theory of the antiretroviral treatment adherence club intervention in the Western Cape Province, South Africa

Abstract

Background: The successful initiation of people living with HIV/AIDS on antiretroviral therapy (ART) in South Africa has engendered challenges of poor retention in care and suboptimal adherence to medication. The adherence club intervention was implemented in the Metropolitan area of the Western Cape Province to address these challenges. The adherence club programme has shown potential to relieve clinic congestion, improve retention in care and enhance treatment adherence in the context of rapidly growing HIV patient populations being initiated on ART. Nevertheless, how and why the adherence club intervention works is not clearly understood. We aimed to elicit an initial programme theory as the first phase of the realist evaluation of the adherence club intervention in the Western Cape Province.

Methods: The realist evaluation approach guided the elicitation study. First, information was obtained from an exploratory qualitative study of programme designers' and managers' assumptions of the intervention. Second, a document review of the design, rollout, implementation and outcome of the adherence clubs followed. Third, a systematic review of available studies on group-based ART adherence support models in Sub-Saharan Africa was done, and finally, a scoping review of social, cognitive and behavioural theories that have been applied to explain adherence to ART. We used the realist evaluation heuristic tool (Intervention-context-actors-mechanism-outcome) to synthesise information from the sources into a configurational map. The configurational mapping, alignment of a specific combination of attributes, was based on the generative causality logic - retroduction.

Results: We identified two alternative theories: The first theory supposes that patients become encouraged, empowered and motivated, through the adherence club intervention to remain in care and adhere to the treatment. The second theory suggests that stable patients on ART are being nudged through club rules and regulations to remain in care and adhere to the treatment with the goal to decongest the primary health care facilities.

Conclusion: The initial programme theory describes how (dynamics) and why (theories) the adherence club intervention is expected to work. By testing theories in "real intervention cases" using the realist evaluation approach, the theories can be modified, refuted and/or reconstructed to elicit a refined theory of how and why the adherence club intervention works.

Keywords: Adherence; Adherence club.; Antiretroviral therapy.; Configurational mapping.; Generative mechanisms.; Intervention-Context-Actor-mechanism-outcome configuration.; Programme theory.; Realist evaluation.; Retention in care.; Retroduction..

Fig. 1

Percentage of patients in adherence clubs in the Cape Metropolitan Region

Fig. 2

Steps employed to elicit the final Intervention-Context-Actor-Mechanism-Outcome configuration hypothesis

Fig. 3

Sources of information for eliciting the initial programme theory

Fig. 4

The Intervention-Context-Actor-Mechanism-Outcome heuristic tool

Fig. 5

An ICAMO representation of the adherence club intervention programme theory

Fig. 6

Standard annual attendance schedule of the adherence club programme

Fig. 7

A pictorial representation of a typical facility-based adherence club session