The role of human papillomaviruses in the pathogenesis and histologic classification of precancerous lesions of the cervix

Abstract

It is clear that the relation between HPV infection and cervical neoplasia is more complex than initially realized. Preliminary molecular virologic data suggest preferential distributions of low- and high-risk HPV types in CIN that tend to correlate with the morphologic appearance. Thus, mild and moderate dysplasias (CIN I and II) contain a diverse distribution of HPV types, including a minority that have a high risk of malignant potential. HPV, therefore, appears to play a major role as a promoter. Neoplastic transformation is probably determined by specific HPV types but, in addition, requires initiation by some other carcinogenic stimulus, e.g., HSV II, cigarette smoking. Despite numerous studies, performed during the past 30 years, the long-term behavior of dysplasia remains uncertain. The natural history of HPV-associated lesions is unknown. Until this information is available, it is recommended that the conventional dysplasia--CIS or CIN nomenclature be used. The presence of associated viral changes can be considered and added to the diagnosis, e.g., "moderate dysplasia (CIN II) with evidence of papillomavirus infection." Treatment should be the same for all intraepithelial lesions, regardless of the presence of morphologic evidence of HPV. In the future, it may be necessary to modify the classification of precancerous lesions of the cervix if it is shown that a specific HPV type induces a characteristic morphologic alteration or that the HPV type, in and of itself, has greater prognostic significance. Until then, confusion will be minimized and management optimized if the conventional dysplasia--CIS or CIN nomenclature is employed.