Optimizing timed AI protocols for Angus beef heifers: Comparison of induction of synchronized ovulation with estradiol cypionate or GnRH

Abstract

This study compared estradiol cypionate (ECP) or GnRH as ovulation inducers at the end of a timed AI (TAI) protocol in Angus heifers. On day 0, heifers (n = 415), between 22 and 24 months of age, were treated with an intravaginal 1 g progesterone (P4) insert and 2 mg of estradiol benzoate. On day 8, heifers had P4 removed, received 500 μg cloprostenol, and were randomized into two groups: ECP [n = 214; 0.5 mg of ECP on day 8] or GnRH [n = 201; 25 μg of GnRH analog licerelin acetate on day 10]. All heifers received TAI on day 10; 48-50 h after P4 insert withdrawal. Estrus was determined by removal of tail paint. Ovaries of heifers were evaluated by ultrasound on day 0 to determine CL presence (with CL = 213, without CL = 202) and on day 10 to measure preovulatory follicle size. Heifers were divided into three categories based on preovulatory follicle diameter: <8.5 mm (smaller than deviation), 8.5-10.9 mm, or ≥11 mm. Pregnancy diagnosis was performed 32 days after TAI. Heifers treated with ECP had greater expression of estrus than GnRH-treated heifers (93.9% vs 67.7%; P < 0.0001), regardless of CL presence at beginning of protocol. Heifers with CL at beginning of protocol had larger preovulatory follicle diameter (10.4 mm vs 9.6 mm; P = 0.0058) and greater pregnancy per AI (P/AI; 61.0% vs 50.5%; P = 0.032) than heifers without CL at day 0. In heifers with CL at day 0, GnRH treatment increased P/AI compared to ECP treatment (68.0% vs 54.9%; P = 0.0498). Expression of estrus was greater in ECP-treated than GnRH-treated heifers that had small (<8.5 mm; 77.1% vs 5.6%; P < 0.001) or medium-sized (8.5-10.9 mm; 98.4% vs. 61.7%) follicles, but not in heifers with large follicles (≥11 mm; 97.9% vs 98.3%). The P/AI was very low in both treatments for heifers with follicles <8.5 mm (ECP-14.3% vs GnRH-16.7%). In heifers with medium-sized follicles (8.5-10.9 mm), ECP treatment tended to increase P/AI compared with GnRH-treated heifers (62.9 vs 46.7%; P = 0.074). In contrast, P/AI was greater for GnRH-treated than ECP-treated heifers with large preovulatory follicles (≥11 mm; 79.7% vs 60.4%; P = 0.032). Thus, the optimal inducer of ovulation in a TAI protocol for beef heifers appears to depend on the presence of a CL at beginning of protocol (GnRH > ECP if CL present) and size of the preovulatory follicle, with ECP increasing expression of estrus and tending to increase fertility in heifers with medium-sized follicles but GnRH increasing fertility in heifers having large preovulatory follicles.

Keywords: Estradiol; GnRH; Heifers; Reproductive management; Timed AI.