Endoscopic laser treatment. II. Comparison of the efficacy of high and low power photocoagulation in control of severely bleeding experimental ulcers in dogs

Abstract

The coagulative efficacy of a "high power" argon laser which delivers 6.5 +/- 1.0 w was compared to that of a "low power" argon laser which delivers 1.0 +/- 0.1 w. The wave-guide angle of divergence was 8 degrees. For the high power laser, the distance between the wave-guide tip and the mucosa varied from 1.0 to 1.5 cm with a delivered power density range of 160 to 487 w per cm2. For the low power laser, the distance between the tip and mucosa varied from 0.7 to 1.3 cm with a power density of 35 to 146 w per cm2. Group A consisted of acute experiments in 6 heparinized dogs in which 51 standard-sized acute gastric ulcers extending into the submucosa were made at laparotomy via a large gastrotomy. Ulcer bleeding rates were quantified into three categories of severity. Within each category, ulcers were randomized to high power, low power, or untreated control. All 19 low power-treated ulcers and 16 untreated controls continued bleeding; 13 of 16 high power-treated ulcers stopped bleeding completely. Representative ulcers were examined histologically. Group B consisted of chronic experiments on 31 ulcers in 7 unheparinized dogs. These ulcers were either treated with high power or left as untreated controls. Dogs were killed and the ulcers were examined histologically at 7, 14, and 28 days. Only rarely did the laser injury penetrate into the muscularis externa. There were no perforations. By 14 days, all lesions were covered with normal surface epithelium. These data encourage further development of congruent to 7.0 w argon laser photocoagulation for eventual clinical use in man.