Direct bronchoprovocation test methods: history 1945-2018

Abstract

Introduction: Bronchoprovocation inhalation challenge tests with direct acting stimuli (e.g. methacholine) are widely used clinically to aid in the diagnosis of asthma. Areas covered: The history of direct challenges with histamine and muscarinic agonists is reviewed. This began with parenteral administration of stimuli with responses monitored clinically and by VC, progressing to inhalation dose-response challenges monitored by FEV₁ and FEV₁/VC ratio, both (the challenge method and the technology to measure FEV₁) developed by Robert Tiffeneau in the mid-1940s. Careful standardization of methods has become appreciated albeit after-the-fact. Recent guidelines recommend standardizing the methacholine PD₂₀ at 400 μg above which a methacholine challenge is considered negative.

Conclusions: The methacholine inhalation test is highly sensitive for a diagnosis of current asthma when symptoms under evaluation are clinically current and when methacholine is inhaled without deep inhalations. Under these circumstances, a methacholine PD₂₀ > 400 μg excludes current asthma with reasonable certainty. PD₂₀ values >25 μg and ≤400 μg will have a variable specificity and positive predictive value for asthma which increases the lower the PD₂₀ and the higher the pre-test probability for a diagnosis of asthma. A PD₂₀ ≤25 μg has high specificity and low sensitivity for asthma.

Keywords: Methacholine; airway hyperresponsiveness (ahr); asthma; deep inhalation bronchoprotection; histamine; inhalation provocation tests; methods standardization.