The Histopathologic Correlation of Bosniak 3 Cyst Subclassification

Abstract

Objective: To evaluate the histopathologic correlation of recently described subclassification of Bosniak category 3 cysts (3s and 3n).

Materials and methods: A total of 106 patients who underwent partial/radical nephrectomy due to a complex renal cyst (≥Bosniak 3) were retrospectively reviewed. All the scans of the patients were reevaluated by 2 experienced uroradiologists. Bosniak 3 cysts were reclassified as 3n (nodularity on the cyst wall/septae) and 3s (septated cysts without nodularity) as described in a recently published paper. Group 1 consisted of patients with Bosniak 3s, Group 2 consisted of patients with Bosniak 3n, and Group 3 consisted of patients with Bosniak 4 cysts. Three groups were compared according to patients' characteristics, radiological findings, histopathologic results, and survival outcomes.

Results: There were 52 patients in Bosniak 3 group and 54 patients in Bosniak 4 group. Mean follow-up was 35.3 months. Among Bosniak 3 cysts, 37 lesions were classified in 3s and 15 were classified in 3n. Malignancy was higher in 3n group than 3s (86.7% vs 54.1%, P= .026). Lesion size was significantly lower for malignant cysts compared to benign ones in the patients with Bosniak 3 lesions (44.2 ± 27.5 vs 80 ± 55.9 P= .005). In the subgroups, malignant lesions were significantly smaller than benign lesions in 3s group similar to general Bosniak 3 group. Most of the Bosniak 3 lesions were organ confined and low grade.

Conclusion: The subclassification of Bosniak 3 cysts as 3s and 3n can help to differentiate highly suspicious malignant lesions from the relatively less suspicious ones.