Comparison of the metabolic control of diabetes achieved by whole pancreas transplantation and pancreatic islet transplantation in rats

Abstract

To compare the long-term effectiveness of whole pancreas transplantation and pancreatic islet transplantation in controlling the metabolic disorders of alloxan diabetes, metabolic studies were performed monthly for 2 years in 4 groups of highly inbred rats: (1) NC-116 nondiabetic controls; (2) DC-273 untreated alloxan-diabetic controls; (3) PDT-182 rats that received syngeneic pancreaticoduodenal transplants shortly after induction of diabetes with alloxan; and (4) IT-92 rats that received an intraportal injection of at least 1500, but usually 2000, syngeneic pancreatic islets shortly after induction of diabetes with alloxan. Whole pancreas transplantation maintained strict metabolic control throughout the 2 years of study. In group PDT, hyperglycemia was abolished; plasma glucose concentration was maintained tightly within the normal range; markedly depressed plasma insulin levels were raised to above normal; glucose tolerance tests had insulin levels above normal and glucose levels that increased less and declined more rapidly than normal; and body weight gain and growth approached normal. In contrast, pancreatic islet transplantation failed to maintain precise metabolic control. In group IT, plasma glucose concentration initially fell to normal but then was elevated significantly above normal beginning with the 3rd posttransplant month; plasma insulin level declined progressively after the 6th posttransplant month; glucose tolerance tests had a diabetic glucose tolerance curve as a result of a markedly deficient plasma insulin response; and body weight gain and growth were significantly less than in group PDT. The results of these long-term metabolic studies may explain the effectiveness of whole pancreas transplantation and the ineffectiveness of pancreatic islet transplantation in preventing diabetic nephropathy.