Neuropsychological characteristics of benign multiple sclerosis patients: A two-year matched cohort study

Abstract

Background: The definition of benign multiple sclerosis (BMS) is still debated. It is mainly based on physical status, however, there is an attempt to involve cognitive functioning or paraclinical factors in order to avoid unnecessary long-term treatment with disease-modifying therapies and to identify these subjects in the early stages of the disease. Therefore the aim of our two-year follow-up study was to investigate the pattern of cognitive functioning and depression in patients with BMS compared to treated relapsing-remitting MS (RRMS) patients and healthy controls.

Methods: A group of 22 BMS patients was tested against matched RRMS patients and healthy controls. All individuals underwent neuropsychological evaluation exploring mood and the cognitive domains most frequently impaired in MS. MS patients were retested at two-year follow-up.

Results: In terms of cognitive functions there were no differences between BMS and RRMS patients either at baseline or at two-year follow-up. Compared to healthy controls BMS patients showed poorer performance in long-term visuo-spatial memory and information processing speed, whereas, complex attention, working memory, long-term verbal memory - despite slower verbal learning - and executive function were found to be intact. RRMS patients showed significant difference in complex attention, long-term visual memory and information processing speed. Cognitive impairment differed in the patient groups in terms of severity. Both patient groups were depressed compared to controls, but significant differences were found only between BMS and healthy individuals.

Conclusion: The results of our study confirm that cognitive functions and mood can be affected in MS independent of disease course and disease modifying treatment. The "benign" label should be treated as only a reference to physical status and non-motor symptoms should be routinely monitored. Without receiving therapy it is an existing entity with longstanding minimal disability.

Keywords: Benign; Cognitive impairment; Depression; Disease modifying treatment; Multiple sclerosis.