Hepatic artery ligation or embolization and locoregional chemotherapy of liver metastases from colorectal cancer

Abstract

If liver metastases are diffuse and spread out in the two lobes of the liver, the question remains as to which treatment should be given. Experimental studies showed that when a tumor grows, its vascular pattern becomes mainly arterial. However, if the tumor is still increasing, its center becomes progressively necrotic. After hepatic artery ligation the blood flow of the liver metastases decreases by 90% in the tumor but depriving the arterial circulation of the tumor is not sufficient to achieve a complete cure since the portal blood supply always saves a rim of neoplastic cells around the necrotic area. On the other hand, local infusion of chemotherapy for liver metastases by the arterial route showed a response rate varying between 34 and 70% and the median survival varying between 8 and 17 months. When FUdR chemotherapy was administered using a totally implantable drug infusion pump no improvement in the survival was observed and moreover a high level of toxicity was described including hepatitis and biliary sclerosis. A combined therapy seems a rational approach to treat tumor cells in surviving to the arterial ligation by perfusing the liver with cytotoxic drugs via the portal vein. Taylor's study was very promising but a randomized phase III clinical trial led by the gastrointestinal cancer group of the EORTC with the aim to evaluate the effectiveness of hepatic artery ligation and portal infusion of 5-FU did not show any difference in the survival of the treated patients when compared with patients treated by hepatic artery ligation alone. 77 patients were registered. Data are now available for 55 patients, respectively 30 and 25 patients in the treated group and in the control group. In both groups the median time to progression was 6 months and the median survival time was 12 months. 20% of the patients treated by hepatic artery ligation and portal chemotherapy had a response, one of them with a complete response, 5 with partial response and 14 patients without significant change in the size of their metastases. On the contrary, in the group treated by hepatic artery ligation alone, only one patient had a partial response with 13 patients having no change in the size of their metastases.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)