An Appreciative Inquiry Approach to the Core Competencies: Taking it From Theory to Practice

Abstract

Objective: To operationalize the surgical core competencies by using a qualitative inquiry strategy to explore how surgical competence is behaviorally demonstrated by faculty.

Design: Categorical general and vascular surgery residents completed a survey soliciting opinions regarding which faculty were deemed most representative of each core competency. The surveys served as a theoretical sample, as surgeons selected were then interviewed, and interviews transcribed. A qualitative research approach using grounded theory coding methods was used for transcript analysis. Iterative coding was performed, and emergent themes were then extracted from transcript analysis.

Setting: Southern Illinois University School of Medicine, Department of Surgery in Springfield, IL, a tertiary academic center.

Participants: Fourteen of 19 residents completed the survey (74% response rate). Two surgeons were selected for each competency. A total of 7 interviews were performed, with 4 surgeons being chosen for 2 competencies.

Results: Emergent themes revealed that competent surgeons shared qualities that drove their development and execution of each competency. These qualities included self-awareness, a selfless character, responsibility and ownership, context awareness, reliance on relationships and community, and a pattern of habit formation and discipline. Additionally, the competencies were noted to be pursued in an interrelated and interdependent fashion.

Conclusions: Surgeons deemed competent in any core domain shared common qualities. Further study exploring how each of these is identified, developed and taught is warranted. The competencies are an inter-related matrix whose development and execution correlates with foundational personal disciplines.

Keywords: ACGME core competencies; Competency-based education; Educational milestones; Grounded theory; Interpersonal and Communication Skills; Practice-Based Learning and Improvement; Professionalism; Surgical competency.