The relationship between animal and plant protein intake and overall diet quality in young adults

Abstract

Background & aims: Overall diet quality is a key predictor of disease risk and mortality. Diets higher in animal protein have been associated with increased disease risk and all-cause mortality. However, the source of protein consumed will inevitably influence the intake of other macronutrients and micronutrients which can also play a role in the onset of disease. The aim of the present study was to assess the relationship between animal and plant protein intake and overall diet quality in young adult females and males.

Methods: Dietary intake was assessed via 3-day food log (n = 150; 53% females) and data were analyzed using the Nutrition Data Systems for Research (NDSR).

Results: Females and males consuming <70% of their protein from animal sources had higher scores on a modified Healthy Eating Index (HEI) compared those consuming >70% of their protein from animal sources. Males scored lower than females on the modified HEI regardless of protein source intake variation.

Conclusions: Our findings suggest that overall diet quality differs with varying protein source consumption and eating <70% of protein from animal sources might lead to a better score on the HEI. Future research investigating protein source and disease risk should examine overall dietary quality as a potential effect modifier.

Keywords: Animal protein; Diet quality; Disease risk; Plant protein; Protein source.