Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
. 2020 May 1;6(5):685-695.
doi: 10.1001/jamaoncol.2019.6716.

Global Retinoblastoma Presentation and Analysis by National Income Level

Global Retinoblastoma Study GroupIdo Didi Fabian  1   2 Elhassan Abdallah  3 Shehu U Abdullahi  4 Rula A Abdulqader  5 Sahadatou Adamou Boubacar  6 Dupe S Ademola-Popoola  7 Adedayo Adio  8 Armin R Afshar  9 Priyanka Aggarwal  10 Ada E Aghaji  11 Alia Ahmad  12 Marliyanti N R Akib  13 Lamis Al Harby  14 Mouroge H Al Ani  15 Aygun Alakbarova  16 Silvia Alarcón Portabella  17 Safaa A F Al-Badri  18 Ana Patricia A Alcasabas  19 Saad A Al-Dahmash  20 Amanda Alejos  21 Ernesto Alemany-Rubio  22 Amadou I Alfa Bio  23 Yvania Alfonso Carreras  24 Christiane Al-Haddad  25 Hamoud H Y Al-Hussaini  26 Amany M Ali  27 Donjeta B Alia  28 Mazin F Al-Jadiry  18 Usama Al-Jumaily  29 Hind M Alkatan  20 Charlotta All-Eriksson  30 Ali A R M Al-Mafrachi  31 Argentino A Almeida  32 Khalifa M Alsawidi  33 Athar A S M Al-Shaheen  5 Entissar H Al-Shammary  34 Primawita O Amiruddin  35 Romanzo Antonino  36 Nicholas J Astbury  1 Hatice T Atalay  37 La-Ongsri Atchaneeyasakul  38 Rose Atsiaya  39 Taweevat Attaseth  40 Than H Aung  41 Silvia Ayala  42 Baglan Baizakova  43 Julia Balaguer  44 Ruhengiz Balayeva  16 Walentyna Balwierz  45 Honorio Barranco  44 Covadonga Bascaran  1 Maja Beck Popovic  46 Raquel Benavides  47 Sarra Benmiloud  48 Nissrine Bennani Guebessi  49 Rokia C Berete  50 Jesse L Berry  51 Anirban Bhaduri  52 Sunil Bhat  53 Shelley J Biddulph  54 Eva M Biewald  55 Nadia Bobrova  56 Marianna Boehme  55 H C Boldt  57 Maria Teresa B C Bonanomi  58 Norbert Bornfeld  55 Gabrielle C Bouda  59 Hédi Bouguila  60 Amaria Boumedane  61 Rachel C Brennan  62 Bénédicte G Brichard  63 Jassada Buaboonnam  38 Patricia Calderón-Sotelo  64 Doris A Calle Jara  65 Jayne E Camuglia  66 Miriam R Cano  67 Michael Capra  68 Nathalie Cassoux  69 Guilherme Castela  70 Luis Castillo  71 Jaume Català-Mora  72 Guillermo L Chantada  72   73   74 Shabana Chaudhry  75 Sonal S Chaugule  76 Argudit Chauhan  77 Bhavna Chawla  78 Violeta S Chernodrinska  79 Faraja S Chiwanga  80 Tsengelmaa Chuluunbat  81 Krzysztof Cieslik  82 Ruellyn L Cockcroft  83 Codruta Comsa  84 Zelia M Correa  85 Maria G Correa Llano  72 Timothy W Corson  86 Kristin E Cowan-Lyn  87 Monika Csóka  88 Xuehao Cui  89 Isac V Da Gama  90 Wantanee Dangboon  91 Anirban Das  92 Sima Das  93 Jacquelyn M Davanzo  94 Alan Davidson  95 Patrick De Potter  63 Karina Q Delgado  96 Hakan Demirci  97 Laurence Desjardins  98 Rosdali Y Diaz Coronado  99 Helen Dimaras  100 Andrew J Dodgshun  101 Craig Donaldson  102 Carla R Donato Macedo  103 Monica D Dragomir  84 Yi Du  104 Magritha Du Bruyn  105 Kemala S Edison  106 I Wayan Eka Sutyawan  107 Asmaa El Kettani  49 Amal M Elbahi  33 James E Elder  108   109 Dina Elgalaly  110 Alaa M Elhaddad  110 Moawia M Ali Elhassan  111 Mahmoud M Elzembely  27 Vera A Essuman  112 Ted Grimbert A Evina  113 Zehra Fadoo  114 Adriana C Fandiño  73 Mohammad Faranoush  115 Oluyemi Fasina  116 Delia D P G Fernández  117 Ana Fernández-Teijeiro  118 Allen Foster  1 Shahar Frenkel  119 Ligia D Fu  120 Soad L Fuentes-Alabi  121 Brenda L Gallie  100 Moira Gandiwa  122 Juan L Garcia  123 David García Aldana  124 Pascale Y Gassant  24 Jennifer A Geel  125 Fariba Ghassemi  126 Ana V Girón  21 Zelalem Gizachew  127 Marco A Goenz  121 Aaron S Gold  128 Maya Goldberg-Lavid  129 Glen A Gole  66 Nir Gomel  130 Efren Gonzalez  131 Graciela Gonzalez Perez  132 Liudmira González-Rodríguez  22 Henry N Garcia Pacheco  133 Jaime Graells  134 Liz Green  135 Pernille A Gregersen  136 Nathalia D A K Grigorovski  137 Koffi M Guedenon  138 D Sanjeeva Gunasekera  139 Ahmet K Gündüz  140 Himika Gupta  141 Sanjiv Gupta  142 Theodora Hadjistilianou  143 Patrick Hamel  144 Syed A Hamid  145 Norhafizah Hamzah  146 Eric D Hansen  147 J William Harbour  148 M Elizabeth Hartnett  147 Murat Hasanreisoglu  37 Sadiq Hassan  4 Shadab Hassan  149 Stanislava Hederova  150 Jose Hernandez  151 Lorelay Marie Carcamo Hernandez  96 Laila Hessissen  152 Diriba F Hordofa  153 Laura C Huang  154 G B Hubbard  155 Marlies Hummlen  156 Kristina Husakova  150 Allawi N Hussein Al-Janabi  34 Russo Ida  36 Vesna R Ilic  157 Vivekaraj Jairaj  158 Irfan Jeeva  114 Helen Jenkinson  159 Xunda Ji  89 Dong Hyun Jo  160 Kenneth P Johnson  161 William J Johnson  162 Michael M Jones  102 Theophile B Amani Kabesha  163 Rolande L Kabore  59 Swathi Kaliki  164 Abubakar Kalinaki  165 Mehmet Kantar  166 Ling-Yuh Kao  167 Tamar Kardava  168 Rejin Kebudi  169 Tomas Kepak  170 Naama Keren-Froim  129 Zohora J Khan  171 Hussain A Khaqan  172 Phara Khauv  173 Wajiha J Kheir  174 Vikas Khetan  175 Alireza Khodabande  126 Zaza Khotenashvili  168 Jonathan W Kim  51 Jeong Hun Kim  176 Hayyam Kiratli  177 Tero T Kivelä  178 Artur Klett  179 Jess Elio Kosh Komba Palet  180 Dalia Krivaitiene  181 Mariana Kruger  182 Kittisak Kulvichit  183 Mayasari W Kuntorini  35 Alice Kyara  80 Eva S Lachmann  184 Carol P S Lam  185 Geoffrey C Lam  186 Scott A Larson  57 Slobodanka Latinovic  187 Kelly D Laurenti  188 Bao Han A Le  189 Karin Lecuona  190 Amy A Leverant  191 Cairui Li  192 Ben Limbu  193 Quah Boon Long  194 Juan P López  195 Robert M Lukamba  196 Livia Lumbroso  98 Sandra Luna-Fineman  197 Delfitri Lutfi  198 Lesia Lysytsia  199 George N Magrath  162 Amita Mahajan  200 Abdul Rahim Majeed  135 Erika Maka  88 Mayuri Makan  201 Emil K Makimbetov  202 Chatonda Manda  122 Nieves Martín Begue  17 Lauren Mason  203 John O Mason 3rd  203 Ibrahim O Matende  39 Miguel Materin  174 Clarissa C D S Mattosinho  137 Marchelo Matua  204 Ismail Mayet  54 Freddy B Mbumba  205 John D McKenzie  108   206 Aurora Medina-Sanson  207 Azim Mehrvar  208 Aemero A Mengesha  209 Vikas Menon  210 Gary John V D Mercado  19 Marilyn B Mets  188 Edoardo Midena  211 Divyansh K C Mishra  212 Furahini G Mndeme  213 Ahmed A Mohamedani  214 Mona T Mohammad  215 Annette C Moll  216 Margarita M Montero  217 Rosa A Morales  64 Claude Moreira  218 Prithvi Mruthyunjaya  154 Mchikirwa S Msina  213 Gerald Msukwa  122 Sangeeta S Mudaliar  141 Kangwa I Muma  219 Francis L Munier  220 Gabriela Murgoi  84 Timothy G Murray  128 Kareem O Musa  221 Asma Mushtaq  12 Hamzah Mustak  190 Okwen M Muyen  222 Gita Naidu  54 Akshay Gopinathan Nair  223   224 Larisa Naumenko  225 Paule Aïda Ndoye Roth  226 Yetty M Nency  227 Vladimir Neroev  228 Hang Ngo  229 Rosa M Nieves  217 Marina Nikitovic  157 Elizabeth D Nkanga  230 Henry Nkumbe  113 Murtuza Nuruddin  231 Mutale Nyaywa  232 Ghislaine Obono-Obiang  233 Ngozi C Oguego  11 Andrzej Olechowski  82 Scott C N Oliver  234 Peter Osei-Bonsu  235 Diego Ossandon  236 Manuel A Paez-Escamilla  148 Halimah Pagarra  13 Sally L Painter  159 Vivian Paintsil  235 Luisa Paiva  237 Bikramjit P Pal  238 Mahesh Shanmugam Palanivelu  212 Ruzanna Papyan  239 Raffaele Parrozzani  211 Manoj Parulekar  159 Claudia R Pascual Morales  151 Katherine E Paton  240 Katarzyna Pawinska-Wasikowska  45 Jacob Pe'er  119 Armando Peña  120 Sanja Peric  241 Chau T M Pham  242 Remezo Philbert  243 David A Plager  86 Pavel Pochop  244 Rodrigo A Polania  245 Vladimir G Polyakov  246   247 Manca T Pompe  248 Jonathan J Pons  249 Daphna Prat  2 Vireak Prom  175 Ignatius Purwanto  250 Ali O Qadir  251 Seema Qayyum  12 Jiang Qian  252 Ardizal Rahman  106 Salman Rahman  9 Jamalia Rahmat  146 Purnima Rajkarnikar  193 Rajesh Ramanjulu  212 Aparna Ramasubramanian  77 Marco A Ramirez-Ortiz  253 Léa Raobela  254 Riffat Rashid  255 M Ashwin Reddy  14 Ehud Reich  256 Lorna A Renner  257 David Reynders  258 Dahiru Ribadu  259 Mussagy M Riheia  260 Petra Ritter-Sovinz  261 Duangnate Rojanaporn  40 Livia Romero  134 Soma R Roy  231 Raya H Saab  262 Svetlana Saakyan  228 Ahmed H Sabhan  18 Mandeep S Sagoo  263 Azza M A Said  264 Rohit Saiju  193 Beatriz Salas  265 Sonsoles San Román Pacheco  266 Gissela L Sánchez  267 Phayvanh Sayalith  268 Trish A Scanlan  80 Amy C Schefler  42 Judy Schoeman  258 Ahad Sedaghat  269 Stefan Seregard  30 Rachna Seth  270 Ankoor S Shah  131 Shawkat A Shakoor  271 Manoj K Sharma  272 Sadik T Sherief  127 Nandan G Shetye  273 Carol L Shields  274 Sorath Noorani Siddiqui  149 Sidi Sidi Cheikh  275 Sónia Silva  70 Arun D Singh  94 Niharika Singh  175 Usha Singh  276 Penny Singha  91 Rita S Sitorus  277 Alison H Skalet  278 Hendrian D Soebagjo  198 Tetyana Sorochynska  56 Grace Ssali  279 Andrew W Stacey  280 Sandra E Staffieri  108   281 Erin D Stahl  282 Christina Stathopoulos  220 Branka Stirn Kranjc  248 David K Stones  283 Caron Strahlendorf  284 Maria Estela Coleoni Suarez  285 Sadia Sultana  255 Xiantao Sun  286 Meryl Sundy  278 Rosanne Superstein  144 Eddy Supriyadi  250 Supawan Surukrattanaskul  287 Shigenobu Suzuki  288 Karel Svojgr  289 Fatoumata Sylla  290 Gevorg Tamamyan  239 Deborah Tan  194 Alketa Tandili  28 Fanny F Tarrillo Leiva  291 Maryam Tashvighi  208 Bekim Tateshi  292 Edi S Tehuteru  293 Luiz F Teixeira  103   294 Kok Hoi Teh  146 Tuyisabe Theophile  295 Helen Toledano  296 Doan L Trang  242 Fousseyni Traoré  297 Sumalin Trichaiyaporn  287 Samuray Tuncer  298 Harba Tyau-Tyau  299 Ali B Umar  4 Emel Unal  300 Ogul E Uner  155 Steen F Urbak  301 Tatiana L Ushakova  246   247 Rustam H Usmanov  302 Sandra Valeina  303 Milo van Hoefen Wijsard  216 Adisai Varadisai  183 Liliana Vasquez  291 Leon O Vaughan  87 Nevyana V Veleva-Krasteva  79 Nishant Verma  142 Andi A Victor  277 Maris Viksnins  303 Edwin G Villacís Chafla  65 Vicktoria Vishnevskia-Dai  2 Tushar Vora  273 Antonio E Wachtel  99 Werner Wackernagel  304 Keith Waddell  204 Patricia D Wade  305 Amina H Wali  306 Yi-Zhuo Wang  307 Avery Weiss  280 Matthew W Wilson  308 Amelia D C Wime  237 Atchareeya Wiwatwongwana  309 Damrong Wiwatwongwana  309 Charlotte Wolley Dod  17 Phanthipha Wongwai  310 Daoman Xiang  311 Yishuang Xiao  312 Jason C Yam  185 Huasheng Yang  313 Jenny M Yanga  314 Muhammad A Yaqub  315 Vera A Yarovaya  316 Andrey A Yarovoy  316 Huijing Ye  313 Yacoub A Yousef  215 Putu Yuliawati  107 Arturo M Zapata López  99 Ekhtelbenina Zein  317 Chengyue Zhang  318 Yi Zhang  307 Junyang Zhao  318 Xiaoyu Zheng  319 Katsiaryna Zhilyaeva  225 Nida Zia  145 Othman A O Ziko  264 Marcia Zondervan  1 Richard Bowman  1   320
Affiliations

Global Retinoblastoma Presentation and Analysis by National Income Level

Global Retinoblastoma Study Group et al. JAMA Oncol. .

Erratum in

  • Error in Coauthor's Name.
    [No authors listed] [No authors listed] JAMA Oncol. 2020 Nov 1;6(11):1815. doi: 10.1001/jamaoncol.2020.5133. JAMA Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32970106 Free PMC article. No abstract available.

Abstract

Importance: Early diagnosis of retinoblastoma, the most common intraocular cancer, can save both a child's life and vision. However, anecdotal evidence suggests that many children across the world are diagnosed late. To our knowledge, the clinical presentation of retinoblastoma has never been assessed on a global scale.

Objectives: To report the retinoblastoma stage at diagnosis in patients across the world during a single year, to investigate associations between clinical variables and national income level, and to investigate risk factors for advanced disease at diagnosis.

Design, setting, and participants: A total of 278 retinoblastoma treatment centers were recruited from June 2017 through December 2018 to participate in a cross-sectional analysis of treatment-naive patients with retinoblastoma who were diagnosed in 2017.

Main outcomes and measures: Age at presentation, proportion of familial history of retinoblastoma, and tumor stage and metastasis.

Results: The cohort included 4351 new patients from 153 countries; the median age at diagnosis was 30.5 (interquartile range, 18.3-45.9) months, and 1976 patients (45.4%) were female. Most patients (n = 3685 [84.7%]) were from low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Globally, the most common indication for referral was leukocoria (n = 2638 [62.8%]), followed by strabismus (n = 429 [10.2%]) and proptosis (n = 309 [7.4%]). Patients from high-income countries (HICs) were diagnosed at a median age of 14.1 months, with 656 of 666 (98.5%) patients having intraocular retinoblastoma and 2 (0.3%) having metastasis. Patients from low-income countries were diagnosed at a median age of 30.5 months, with 256 of 521 (49.1%) having extraocular retinoblastoma and 94 of 498 (18.9%) having metastasis. Lower national income level was associated with older presentation age, higher proportion of locally advanced disease and distant metastasis, and smaller proportion of familial history of retinoblastoma. Advanced disease at diagnosis was more common in LMICs even after adjusting for age (odds ratio for low-income countries vs upper-middle-income countries and HICs, 17.92 [95% CI, 12.94-24.80], and for lower-middle-income countries vs upper-middle-income countries and HICs, 5.74 [95% CI, 4.30-7.68]).

Conclusions and relevance: This study is estimated to have included more than half of all new retinoblastoma cases worldwide in 2017. Children from LMICs, where the main global retinoblastoma burden lies, presented at an older age with more advanced disease and demonstrated a smaller proportion of familial history of retinoblastoma, likely because many do not reach a childbearing age. Given that retinoblastoma is curable, these data are concerning and mandate intervention at national and international levels. Further studies are needed to investigate factors, other than age at presentation, that may be associated with advanced disease in LMICs.

PubMed Disclaimer

Conflict of interest statement

Conflict of Interest Disclosures: Dr Berry reports receiving grants from National Cancer Institute (K08CA232344), Wright Foundation, Knights Templar Eye Foundation, American Cancer Society, Hyundai Hope on Wheels, and Childhood Eye Cancer Trust, as well as nonfinancial support from Institute for Families, The Larry and Celia Moh Foundation, and Research to Prevent Blindness. Dr Correa reports receiving personal fees from Castle Biosciences and Immunocore. Dr Diaz Coronado reports receiving support from Merck Sharp & Dohme. Dr Demirci reports receiving support Castle Biosciences and Immunocore. Dr Foster reports receiving grants from the Queen Elizabeth Diamond Jubilee Trust. Dr Gold reports receiving personal fees from Regeneron. Dr Harbour reports receiving royalties and other support from Castle Biosciences. Dr Hartnett reports receiving grants from the National Eye Institute; having a patent issued and a patent pending related to her work in eye care; receiving honoraria from Wolters Kluwer as editor in chief of the textbook Pediatric Retina Disease, Second Edition; receiving honoraria for academic lectures at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, Michigan State University, University of Florida, University of Iowa, Ohio State University, Indiana University, Cole Eye Institute, Scheie Eye Institute, Massachusetts Eye and Ear, and University of Colorado; and receiving paid trips to consult for the National Eye Institute’s National Advisory Eye Council and for grant review for the Knights Templar Eye Foundation. Dr Kivela reports receiving personal fees from Santen. Dr Materin reports receiving personal fees from IDEAYA Biosciences and Castle Biosciences. Dr Nair reports receiving personal fees from HelpMeSee and Carl Zeiss Meditec. Dr Oliver reports receiving grants from Roche. Dr Skalet reports receiving support as a consultant from Castle Biosciences and Immunocore. Dr Soebagjo reports rights to 2 licensed patents. Dr Stahl reports receiving personal fees from Avedro and nonfinancial support from Sydnexis.

Figures

Figure.
Figure.. Cohort Recruitment Flowchart
aPatients from 23 countries with no retinoblastoma centers were treated outside of their country of residence. bInclusion criteria included reporting of country of residence, sex, and laterality. Patients for whom 1 or more of these parameters were not available were not included in the analytic sample.

Comment in

References

    1. MacCarthy A, Birch JM, Draper GJ, et al. . Retinoblastoma: treatment and survival in Great Britain 1963 to 2002. Br J Ophthalmol. 2009;93(1):38-39. doi:10.1136/bjo.2008.139626 - DOI - PubMed
    1. Munier FL, Mosimann P, Puccinelli F, et al. . First-line intra-arterial versus intravenous chemotherapy in unilateral sporadic group D retinoblastoma: evidence of better visual outcomes, ocular survival and shorter time to success with intra-arterial delivery from retrospective review of 20 years of treatment. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017;101(8):1086-1093. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2016-309298 - DOI - PMC - PubMed
    1. Fernandes AG, Pollock BD, Rabito FA. Retinoblastoma in the United States: a 40-year incidence and survival analysis. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2018;55(3):182-188. doi:10.3928/01913913-20171116-03 - DOI - PubMed
    1. Fabian ID, Onadim Z, Karaa E, et al. . The management of retinoblastoma. Oncogene. 2018;37(12):1551-1560. doi:10.1038/s41388-017-0050-x - DOI - PubMed
    1. Yamane T, Kaneko A, Mohri M. The technique of ophthalmic arterial infusion therapy for patients with intraocular retinoblastoma. Int J Clin Oncol. 2004;9(2):69-73. doi:10.1007/s10147-004-0392-6 - DOI - PubMed