The information theory of individuality

Abstract

Despite the near universal assumption of individuality in biology, there is little agreement about what individuals are and few rigorous quantitative methods for their identification. Here, we propose that individuals are aggregates that preserve a measure of temporal integrity, i.e., "propagate" information from their past into their futures. We formalize this idea using information theory and graphical models. This mathematical formulation yields three principled and distinct forms of individuality-an organismal, a colonial, and a driven form-each of which varies in the degree of environmental dependence and inherited information. This approach can be thought of as a Gestalt approach to evolution where selection makes figure-ground (agent-environment) distinctions using suitable information-theoretic lenses. A benefit of the approach is that it expands the scope of allowable individuals to include adaptive aggregations in systems that are multi-scale, highly distributed, and do not necessarily have physical boundaries such as cell walls or clonal somatic tissue. Such individuals might be visible to selection but hard to detect by observers without suitable measurement principles. The information theory of individuality allows for the identification of individuals at all levels of organization from molecular to cultural and provides a basis for testing assumptions about the natural scales of a system and argues for the importance of uncertainty reduction through coarse-graining in adaptive systems.

Keywords: Adaptation; Control; Evolution; Gestalt; Information decomposition; Mutual information; Shannon information; Shared information; Synergy.

Fig. 1

The causal diagram of the system–environment interaction

Fig. 2

Mutual information between two time steps (Total_MI), Entropy of the system (H_sys), colonial (A) and organismal (A_star) individuality, and environmental determination (nC) for different values of ${\alpha }_S$,${\beta }_S$, and for ${\gamma }_S$ (subscript “S” omitted in the figure) with a random environment ${\alpha }_E={\beta }_E={\gamma }_E=0$

Fig. 3

Mutual information between two time steps (Total_MI), Entropy of the system (H_sys), colonial (A) and organismal (A_star) individuality, and environmental determination (nC) for different values of ${\alpha }_S$,${\beta }_S$, and for ${\gamma }_S$ with a correlated environment ${\alpha }_E=2{\beta }_E={\gamma }_E=0$