Rationale of the rare cancer list: a consensus paper from the Joint Action on Rare Cancers (JARC) of the European Union (EU)

Abstract

Background: The Surveillance of Rare Cancers in Europe (RARECARE) project proposed a definition and a list of rare cancers. The Joint Action on Rare Cancers (JARC), launched by the European Union and involving 18 member states and 34 partners, promoted a wide consensus effort to review the list.

Patients and methods: A group of experts was set up, including scientific societies, member state representatives of JARC, representatives of the European Reference Networks dedicated to rare cancers and rare cancer patient advocates. The definition and the list of rare clinical entities, based on the incidence data provided by two European projects (RARECARE and RARECAREnet), were rediscussed through a consensus meeting of the expert panel.

Results: By consensus, it was reiterated that the best criterion for a definition of rare cancers is incidence, rather than prevalence. By consensus, the experts slightly modified the composition of the tiers of rare cancers, according to the definition based on an incidence threshold <6/100 000/year, and grouped all rare cancers within 12 families of rare cancers. Even when defined conservatively this way, rare cancers are not rare collectively, since they correspond to 10%-20% of all cancer cases.

Conclusions: The list of rare cancers reviewed by JARC should be viewed as a tool in the fight against rare cancers and rare diseases. It may help to appreciate that rare cancers are cancers and rare diseases at the same time, combining issues and difficulties of both. We hope that refinements to the list and a wider understanding of its implications may contribute to increase awareness of problems posed by rare cancers and to improve quality of care in a large group of patients with cancer, who may be discriminated against just because of the low frequency of their diseases.

Keywords: cancer registries; incidence; prevalence; rare cancers.

Figure 1

Percentage of rare and common cancers based on: the incidence rate of tier 1 cancer entities (A); incidence rate of tier 2 cancer entities (B); prevalence of tier 1 cancer entities (C); prevalence of tier 2 cancer entities (D).